Celtic literature -- History and criticism; Ireland -- In literature
The glimpses of Highland life he gives in connection with his visits and
colloquies with the people are highly interesting.
“Whatever be the value of this work,” he says, “it is genuine folk-lore,
taken down from the lips of men and women, no part being copied from
books. It is the product of far-away thinking, come down on the long
stream of time. Who the thinkers and whence the stream, who can tell?
Some of the hymns may have been composed within the cloistered cells of
Deny and Iona, and some of the incantations among the cromlechs of
Stonehenge and the standing stones of Callarnis. These poems were
composed by the learned, but they have not come down through the
learned, but through the unlearned—not through the lettered few, but
through the unlettered many, through the crofters and cottars, the
herdsmen and shepherds of the Highlands and Islands.”
“The poems were generally intoned in a low, recitative manner, rising
and falling in slow modulated cadences, charming to hear but difficult
to follow. The music of the hymns had a distinct individuality, in some
respects resembling and in many respects differing from the old
Gregorian chants of the Church. I greatly regret that I was not able to
record this peculiar and beautiful music, probably the music of the old
Celtic Church.”
Following the advice and example of his acquaintance, J. F. Campbell of
Islay, whom he knew for a quarter of a century, Mr. Carmichael gives the
words and names of the reciters. But, unlike Campbell and Mackenzie and
Sinclair, he gives an English rendering of the original in every
instance. Thus, while to the vast majority of this nation _their_
felicitous poems are locked up in the Gaelic, _his_ are available to
all, in chaste and beautiful language, with charming letterpress,
embellished by old Celtic letters, artistically copied by his wife from
the ancient MSS. in Edinburgh and elsewhere.
Speaking of the original, he maintains that, although in decay, the
poems are in verse of a high order, with metre, rhythm, assonance,
alliteration, and every quality to please the ear and to instruct the
mind. Simple dignity, charming grace, passionate devotion, characterise
most of these pieces. Again and again he laid down his self-imposed
task, feeling unable to render the intense power and supreme beauty of
the original Gaelic into adequate English; but he persevered, thus
placing a stone as it were upon the cairn of those who composed and of
those who transmitted the work.
And now, a few characteristic specimens from the book may fitly close
this study. The first is an incantation beginning:—
The wicked who would do me harm,
May he take the (throat) disease
Globularly, spirally, circularly,
Fluxy, pellety, horny-grim, etc.
But scarcely any English can convey the vengeance of the vernacular.
Even the sounds are terrifying:—
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account