The Little Review, July 1914 (Vol. 1, No. 5)Various
General
The Little Review, July 1914 (Vol. 1, No. 5)
Various
Literature, Modern -- 20th century -- Periodicals
The reason I say the situation is abnormal is this: usually when
a mother objects to her daughters' behavior it is on some
definite basis of opposing the things they _do_--like going to
too many parties or falling in love with the wrong man. You have
very little fault to find with the things we do. Your objections
are on a basis of what we _are_--or, rather, of what we _are
not_: that we are not orthodox, that we are not hypocrites, that
we are not the kind of daughters the Victorians approved of.
"Hypocrites" will sound paradoxical; but you have confessed that
you would rather have us lie to you than to disagree with you;
that you would rather have us be sentimental about "the way a
girl should treat her mother" than to learn how we ought to treat
ourselves. You call that being "respectful" and think that
harmony is possible only under such conditions. We call it being
"insulting," and think that it's the one sure way of destroying
any chance of harmony. If we respect you it must be because we
think you worthy of the truth: anything else is degrading to both
sides.
You'll say you can't be satisfied to live with us and not give
advice and all the other things that are part of a mother's duty.
You may give all the advice you want to; the keynote of the new
situation will be that we'll take the advice if we believe it's
right; if not we'll ignore it, just as a man ignores his friend's
advice when he feels it to be wrong. Of course the wise person
doesn't give much advice; he simply lives his life the best way
he knows how. That's the only bid he can make for emulation. If
we tell you that we don't approve of the creed you have made you
mustn't be surprised if we try to formulate one of our own.
There's no reason for us to ask you to change just because we're
your daughters. You must do as you believe. But you must grant us
the same privilege.
We disagree about fundamentals. If our beliefs were merely the
vague, unformed ideas of children you might try to change them.
But it's too late now. So we can live together harmoniously only
if we give up the foolish attempts at "influencing."
We're not living three generations ago. We've had Shaw since
then, and parents and children aren't doing the insulting things
to each other they used to do. Among intelligent people some of
the old issues can never raise their heads again. And so, it's
for you to decide:--whether we shall build on the new foundation
together or separately.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account