The logic of modern physicsBridgman, P. W. (Percy Williams)
Philosophy
The logic of modern physics
Bridgman, P. W. (Percy Williams)
Physics -- Philosophy
If we are right in supposing that physical evidence gives no warrant for
the idea that nature is finite downward, we have not only repudiated the
thesis of simplicity but we have also made a very important observation
on the other general thesis mentioned at the beginning of this chapter,
namely, the thesis of physical determinism. By determinism we understand
the belief that the future of the whole universe, or of an isolated part
of it, is determined in terms of a complete description of its present
condition. [What we mean by present condition will be discussed later.]
It is popularly assumed that every physicist subscribes to some such
thesis as this. But now if there is infinite structure even in a small
isolated part of the universe, a complete description of it is
impossible, and the doctrine as stated must be abandoned. It seems to me
that all present physical evidence prepares us to admit this
possibility. I suppose, however, that most physicists would subscribe to
some modification of the original thesis, perhaps along the following
lines. Given a description of an isolated part of the physical universe
in the most complete terms that have physical meaning, that is, down to
the smallest elements of which our physical operations give us
cognizance, then the future history of the system is determined within a
certain penumbra of uncertainty, this penumbra growing broader as we
penetrate to finer details of the structure of the system or as times
goes on, until eventually all but certain very general properties of the
original system, such as its total energy, are forever lost in the haze,
and we have a system which was unpredictable. I suppose that it is a
further conviction of at least many physicists that by sufficiently
refining our measurements, the amount of haze at any fixed point in the
future may be made indefinitely small, and many might even go further
and hope by studying the haze (perhaps statistically) to obtain some
inferential evidence of structure beyond that yet experienced. In fact
it may be that this last contains the germs of the ultimate method of
investigation, if we ever reach a stage when we can no longer refine our
methods of measurement.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account