The logic of modern physicsBridgman, P. W. (Percy Williams)
Philosophy
The logic of modern physics
Bridgman, P. W. (Percy Williams)
Physics -- Philosophy
As the dimensions become smaller, certain difficulties become
increasingly important that were negligible on a larger scale. In
carrying out physically the operations equivalent to our concepts, there
are a host of practical precautions to be taken which could be
explicitly enumerated with difficulty, but of which nevertheless any
practical physicist is conscious. Suppose, for example, we measure
length tactually by a combination of Johanssen gauges. In piling these
together, we must be sure that they are clean, and are thus in actual
contact. Particles of mechanical dirt first engage our attention. Then
as we go to smaller dimensions we perhaps have to pay attention to
adsorbed films of moisture, then at still smaller dimensions to adsorbed
films of gas, until finally we have to work in a vacuum, which must be
the more nearly complete the smaller the dimensions. About the time that
we discover the necessity for a complete vacuum, we discover that the
gauges themselves are atomic in structure, that they have no definite
boundaries, and therefore no definite length, but that the length is a
hazy thing, varying rapidly in time between certain limits. We treat
this situation as best we can by taking a time average of the apparent
positions of the boundaries, assuming that along with the decrease of
dimensions we have acquired a corresponding extravagant increase in
nimbleness. But as the dimensions get smaller continually, the
difficulties due to this haziness increase indefinitely in percentage
effect, and we are eventually driven to give up altogether. We have made
the discovery that there are _essential_ physical limitations to the
operations which defined the concept of length. [We perhaps do not
regard the substitution of optical for tactual space on the astronomical
scale as compelled by the same sort of physical necessity, because I
suppose the possible eventual landing of men in the moon will always be
one of the dreams of humanity.] At the same time that we have come to
the end of our rope with our Johanssen gauge procedure, our companion
with the microscope has been encountering difficulties due to the finite
wave length of light; this difficulty he has been able to minimize by
using light of progressively shorter wave lengths, but he has eventually
had to stop on reaching X-rays. Of course this optical procedure with
the microscope is more convenient, and is therefore adopted in practice.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account