The logic of modern physicsBridgman, P. W. (Percy Williams)
Philosophy
The logic of modern physics
Bridgman, P. W. (Percy Williams)
Physics -- Philosophy
Another indispensable and most interesting construct is that of the
atom. This is evidently a construct, because no one ever directly
experienced an atom, and its existence is entirely inferential. The atom
was invented to explain constant combining weights in chemistry. For a
long time there was no other experimental evidence of its existence, and
it remained a pure invention, without physical reality, useful in
discussing a certain group of phenomena. It is one of the most
fascinating things in physics to trace the accumulation of independent
new physical information all pointing to the atom, until now we are as
convinced of its physical reality as of our hands and feet.
A construct which had to be abandoned because it did not turn out to
have physical reality, and which furthermore was not sufficiently useful
in the light of newly discovered phenomena, was that of a caloric fluid.
The notion of "physical reality" is not of prime importance to this
discussion of the character of our constructs; our definition of the
meaning of physical reality may not appeal to everyone. The essential
point is that our constructs fall into two classes: those to which no
physical operations correspond other than those which enter the
definition of the construct, and those which admit of other operations,
or which could be defined in several alternative ways in terms of
physically distinct operations. This difference in the character of
constructs may be expected to correspond to essential physical
differences, and these physical differences are much too likely to be
overlooked in the thinking of physicists. We must always be on our guard
not to forget the physical differences between a thing like a stress in
an elastic body and an electromagnetic field.
The moral of all this is that constructs are most useful and even
unavoidable things, but that they may have great dangers, and that a
careful critique may be necessary to avoid reading into them
implications for which there is no warrant in experience, and which may
most profoundly affect our physical outlook and course of action.
THE RÔLE OF MATHEMATICS IN PHYSICS
Practically all the formulations of theoretical physics are made in
mathematical terms; in fact to obtain such formulations is generally
felt to be the goal of theoretical physics. It is then evidently
pertinent to consider what the nature of the mathematics is to which we
assign so prominent a rôle.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account