The logic of modern physicsBridgman, P. W. (Percy Williams)
Philosophy
The logic of modern physics
Bridgman, P. W. (Percy Williams)
Physics -- Philosophy
An exact analysis from the operational point of view of the significance
of the equations at high velocities has perhaps never been made, and is
not necessary for our immediate purpose. The discussion has brought out,
however, that the number of physically independent concepts has been cut
down by two at least, in that we have made purely formal definitions of
the meaning of quantity of electricity, and of the force exerted by a
field on a charge at high velocity. There is no reason to think that
there is anything unique about this analysis, or that formal definitions
might not have been given to other concepts than charge and force. We
can only state that as far as physical content goes the equations have
at least two degrees of freedom. It should then be possible to find
quite different sorts of equations which agree equally well with
experience. In particular, since we have seen that the force on a moving
charge has no meaning in terms of independent operations, it should be
possible by arbitrary definition to make this force any function of
velocity that we please (of course reducing to the proper value at low
velocities), and then to determine the other equations so that the
entire group of equations is consistent with experiment. So far as I
know, no one has tried to give such a modified set of equations, and
indeed there is no particular reason why anyone should bother to do
this, because the present equations are simple enough, and the modified
equations, although perhaps differing greatly in appearance from the
present ones, would have no advantage in any greater or different
physical content.
But there is no reason to think that the present state of affairs will
always continue. We have seen that the decrease in the number of
concepts corresponds to our inability to measure as many sorts of
physical things at high velocities as at low. Now it is the task of the
future experimenter so to refine the possibilities of measurement at
high velocities as to restore these two degrees of freedom. In
particular, mass should be made measurable in mechanical terms at high
velocities. When this restoration has been made, and all the quantities
in our equations receive independent physical meaning, the significance
of the equations in terms of operations will be quite altered, although
the formal appearance will be unchanged. We must then be prepared to
find, as always when we change the range of phenomena, that the
equations in their present form do not correspond to the facts at all,
and that one of the alternative forms allowed by our present two degrees
of freedom is the correct form. But until the new experimental facts
have been obtained, it seems hardly worth while to attempt to specify
the doubly infinite variety of forms which the equations might have
consistently with present experiment.[23]
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account