The Logic of Vegetarianism: Essays and DialoguesSalt, Henry S.
Philosophy
The Logic of Vegetarianism: Essays and Dialogues
Salt, Henry S.
Vegetarianism
It has been well shown by Dr. J. Oldfield, in the _New Century
Review_, October 1898, that "omnivorism" in the hoggish sense,
is _not_ characteristic of progressive mankind. "The higher we
go in the scale of life, the more we find _selection_ taking
the place of omnivorism. The more complex the organism, the
greater its selective capacity. 'Selection,' then, rather than
'omnivorism,' should be the watch-cry of the human race
evolving upward."
But let us return to our monkeys.
SCIENTIST: You just now quoted the gorilla as a
frugivorous animal, but, on further consideration, I
cannot admit him to be so. He is omnivorous—like man. I
have Sir Richard Owen's authority for it.
VEGETARIAN: What! Does the ape rush upon the antelopes,
and rend them with those canine teeth of his? How
horrible!
SCIENTIST: Not exactly that; but it was stated by Sir
Henry Thompson that "Sally," the large chimpanzee once
so popular in the Zoological Gardens, was not
infrequently supplied with animal food.
VEGETARIAN: Well, and how does that prove that the
chimpanzee is not naturally frugivorous? I should
imagine that any one of us, if placed in a cage, and
stared at all the year round by a throng of gaping
visitors, might be liable to aberrations. Even a
vegetarian might do the same.
SCIENTIST: But in their wild state also the baboons are
known to prey on lizards, young birds, eggs, etc., when
they can get them. Perhaps you were not aware of this
when you called the apes frugivorous?
VEGETARIAN: I was quite aware of it, and in view of the
exceedingly small importance of these casual pilferings
as compared with their staple diet, I maintain that they
_are_, for all practical purposes, frugivorous. Indeed,
so far from this mischievous penchant of the apes being
an argument against vegetarianism, it is most suggestive
as explaining how the early savages may have passed,
almost by accident at first, from a frugivorous to a
mixed diet.
SCIENTIST: Well, at any rate, it indicates that apes
have a tendency to become omnivorous.
VEGETARIAN: Yes, if you like to express it so; and it
is still more evident that men have that tendency. But
the question is whether the tendency is rightly
interpreted as giving a sanction to _flesh-eating_. For
flesh-eating, as we use the term, means the breeding,
destroying, and devouring of highly-organised mammals,
and is a very different thing from the egg and lizard
hunting in which the monkeys sometimes indulge. If you
would confine your flesh-eating to a few insects and
nestlings, you would have a better right to quote the
example of the apes.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account