If it is necessary that man grasp the truth of things before he can
determine the laws of things, we cannot fail to see how important it is
that he have a proper theory of knowledge.
Man’s idea of law will correspond to his theory of knowledge. When the
French people accepted Locke’s theory of knowing they immediately applied
it to the laws, establishments, and institutions of the nation. They
concluded logically, if all knowledge is of sensations, then there can
be no authority for the belief in God, the immortality of the soul, or
the divinity of law. These are universal and transcendent facts, but
the mind has no capacity to know universal or transcendent facts. So
society was to be dissolved into its constituent atoms, in order that
individuals could arrange their lives on a universal, go-as-you-please
principle. All existing laws and institutions were to be obliterated.
Everything that was up was to be put down. There are to-day, scattered
through the civilized states of Europe and in some parts of the United
States, men who want to emancipate the people from the dominion of all
authority. All this grows out of the fashionable and sensational theory
of knowledge taught first by John Locke and David Hume, and within recent
years by John Stuart Mill and Herbert Spencer. Here is the source of
anarchy. There is not an influential anarchist in the world, but is one
upon the basis of the physiological theory of knowledge. There is no
objective reality, but such as is composed of material atoms. These have
got their arrangement and collocations without the agency of any great
co-ordinating mind. They come together in pairs and clusters and groups,
by the aid of no power but such as issues from the unknowable. A man
is no more a criminal for killing people than is the Mississippi River
for overflowing its banks and drowning people. Men are mere products of
nature, and their thoughts are only secretions of the brain. Laws and
institutions are just the brain deposits of animals we call men, as dams
across rivers and cells in gums are the deposits of the brains of beavers
and bees.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account