The meaning of a liberal educationMartin, Everett Dean
Philosophy
The meaning of a liberal education
Martin, Everett Dean
Education
Even in the best of educational institutions the utilitarian point of
view with its emphasis upon a narrow efficiency has its dangers. It is
the source of that specialization which crams the student’s head full
of information concerning one subject, leaving him in ignorance of all
else and hence unable to gain a proper perspective of the knowledge
that he does possess.
In “Science and the Modern World,” Whitehead says
“The modern chemist is likely to be weak in zoölogy, weaker still
in his general knowledge of the Elizabethan drama, and completely
ignorant of the principles of rhythm in English versification. It
is probably safe to ignore his knowledge of ancient history. Of
course I am speaking of general tendencies; for chemists are no worse
than engineers, or mathematicians, or classical scholars. Effective
knowledge is professionalised knowledge, supported by a restricted
acquaintance with useful subjects subservient to it.
This situation has its dangers. It produces minds in a groove. Each
profession makes progress, but it is progress in its own groove. Now
to be mentally in a groove is to live in contemplating a given set of
abstractions. The groove prevents straying across country, and the
abstraction abstracts from something to which no further attention is
paid. But there is no groove of abstraction which is adequate for the
comprehension of human life....
The dangers arising from this aspect of professionalism are great,
particularly in our democratic societies. The directive force of
reason is weakened. The leading intellects lack balance. They see
this set of circumstances, or that set; but not both sets together.
The task of coordination is left to those who lack either the force
or the character to succeed in some definite career.... The point is
that the discoveries of the nineteenth century were in the direction
of professionalism, so that we are left with no expansion of wisdom
and with greater need of it. Wisdom is the fruit of a balanced
development. It is this balanced growth of individuality which it
should be the aim of education to secure.”
A philosophy which reduces learning to mere efficiency, makes of
education only a means to something other than personal development.
It sees each good as an economic good, a means only, making everything
exist only for the sake of something else to be obtained. But there
are goods which exist for their own sakes and one such good is human
excellence.
In the words of Dr. L. P. Jacks, “The civilization of power aims at
the _exploitation of the world_, which is thought of as a dead or
mechanical thing, existing that men may exploit it. That of culture
aims at the _development of man_, thought of as a citizen of a universe
which can be loved, enjoyed and reverenced: education being the name of
the process which leads him to love, enjoy and reverence it.”
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account