The meaning of a liberal educationMartin, Everett Dean
Philosophy
The meaning of a liberal education
Martin, Everett Dean
Education
There has been much discussion of this question in the universities
and colleges. There are those who deplore the decline of interest in
the classics and philosophy. They say that institutions of higher
learning are becoming mere “intellectual cafeterias,” that the change
from classical education to an elective system embracing all sorts of
vocational courses is a distinct loss, inasmuch as the knowledge so
acquired lacks coordination and balance, while specialization crowds
out the general and cultural subjects that form the foundation of
education.
On the other hand, why should not a University teach anything
that people wish to know? There was once resistance to including
the sciences, chemistry and physics and biology. The liberalizing
effect and cultural value of these subjects is now recognized, and
their usefulness is a social gain. Then why not domestic science,
agriculture, mechanics, business methods? What is wrong with the
schools of business at Harvard and Columbia?
A similar issue exists in secondary education. It is often said that
high schools pay too much regard to college entrance requirements,
since only a small portion of graduates expect to continue their
education. The students have gained only a most superficial
introduction to the classics and have learned nothing practical.
Schools of trade, commerce, and of technology are increasing in number
and the movement for such training is guided by principles of education
very different from those of the classical tradition.
Those of us who are interested in adult education meet the same
problem. Writing of worker’s education Dr. Horace M. Kallen says,
“... The complexity of the tasks of any union official has grown so
great, their variety so considerable, that it is no longer possible
for an official merely to pass from the worker’s bench to the
official’s desk and completely discharge his duties.... Schools
would have to be provided analogous to the schools of business
administration maintained in the colleges.... Out of the instruction
there would in the course of time emerge a communicable permanent
record, on which the necessary accessories of books could be built.
Such a school of officials would be a nucleus from which the
educational process could ultimately radiate into every shop.
“Labor education would finally thus become conversant with control
rather than escape. In such a conversancy more and more of the
energies now seeking relief in the vapors of the social mechanisms
of escape, would find satisfactory enchannelment in the technique of
control.
“It is the essential function of labor education to envisage, to
forecast and to enable this transition. The various arts would then
develop no longer as compensations against, but as expressions
and prophetic fulfillments, as criticisms and mitigations of,
the processes of this movement; they too would more largely be
coterminous with industrial life.”
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account