The meaning of a liberal educationMartin, Everett Dean
Philosophy
The meaning of a liberal education
Martin, Everett Dean
Education
Dewey says that without initiation into the scientific spirit one is
not in possession of the best tools which humanity has so far devised
for effectively directed reflection. In it may be realized that desire
for exact knowledge as different from mere opinion which the ancients
sought. It tests all things in the light of experiment and by appeal
to cold objective fact. It is often said that science is Reason in
contrast with Faith. Certainly the scientist cannot in his research
permit himself to be swayed by religious belief and remain scientific.
He must accept no conclusion on authority or because he wishes to
believe it. But the scientific mind is not, as a matter of fact, as
strictly rationalistic as was the scholastic mind. The logic of the
latter is a formal vindication of The Truth conceived in advance of
knowledge of fact. The reasoning of the former proceeds by a succession
of shrewd guesses which are held to be mere hypothesis until verified
by the facts. This necessity of holding judgment in abeyance, and
of being willing to discard any belief or postulate that may not be
confirmed by objective reality, has the greatest educational value. In
spite of the everlasting deceitfulness and conceit of human nature and
notwithstanding the fact that pompous ignorance and fraud are often
palmed off upon the public as scientific knowledge, I should say,
precisely because of these things, training in scientific methods is
the best device available to the educator for instilling into the human
mind some measure of respect for truth.
To this end Huxley would introduce scientific experimentation into the
elementary school and would establish “scientific Sunday schools,”
“Would there really be anything wrong in using part of Sunday for
the purpose of instructing those who have no other leisure, in a
knowledge of the phenomena of Nature, and of man’s relation to
Nature?
“I should like to see a scientific Sunday-school in every parish,
not for the purpose of superseding any existing means of teaching
the people the things that are for their good, but side by side with
them. I cannot but think that there is room for all of us to work in
helping to bridge over the great abyss of ignorance which lies at our
feet.
“And if any of the ecclesiastical persons to whom I have referred
object that they find it derogatory to the honour of the God whom
they worship, to awaken the minds of the young to the infinite wonder
and majesty of the works which they proclaim His, and to teach them
those laws which must needs be His laws, and therefore of all things
needful for man to know--I can only recommend them to be let blood
and put on low diet. There must be something very wrong going on in
the instrument of logic if it turns out such conclusions from such
premises.”
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account