But the result of the examination was to bring out with fresh force
and vividness the difference between the maxims of Common Sense
Morality (even the strongest and strictest, _e.g._ Veracity and
Good Faith) and the intuitions which I had already attained, _i.e._
the Kantian Principle (of which I now saw the only certain element
in Justice--“treat similar cases similarly”--to be a particular
application), and the Fundamental Principle of Utilitarianism. And this
latter was in perfect harmony with the Kantian Principle. I certainly
could will it to be a universal law that men should act in such a way
as to promote universal happiness; in fact it was the only law that it
was perfectly clear to me that I could thus decisively will, from a
universal point of view.
I was then a Utilitarian again, but on an Intuitional basis.
But further, the reflection on Common Sense Morality which I had gone
through, had continually brought home to me its character as a system
of rules tending to the promotion of general happiness (cf. [_Methods
of Ethics_] pp. 470, 471).
Also the previous reflection on hedonistic method for Book ii. had
shown me its weaknesses. What was then to be done? [The] conservative
attitude [to be observed] towards Common Sense [is] given in chapter
v. of Book iv.: “Adhere generally, deviate and attempt reform only
in exceptional cases in which,--notwithstanding the roughness of
hedonistic method,--the argument against Common Sense is decisive.”
In this state of mind I published my book: I tried to say what I had
found: that the opposition between Utilitarianism and Intuitionism was
due to a misunderstanding. There was indeed a fundamental opposition
between the individual’s interest and either morality, which I could
not solve by any method I had yet found trustworthy, without the
assumption of the moral government of the world: so far I agreed with
both Butler and Kant.
But I could find no real opposition between Intuitionism and
Utilitarianism.... The Utilitarianism of Mill and Bentham seemed to me
to want a basis: that basis could only be supplied by a fundamental
intuition; on the other hand the best examination I could make of the
Morality of Common Sense showed me no clear and self-evident principles
except such as were perfectly consistent with Utilitarianism.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account