The migrations of early culture: A study of the significance of the geographical distribution of the practice of mummification as evidence of the migrations of peoples and the spread of certain customs and beliefsSmith, Grafton Elliot
History
The migrations of early culture: A study of the significance of the geographical distribution of the practice of mummification as evidence of the migrations of peoples and the spread of certain customs and beliefs
Smith, Grafton Elliot
Ethnology; Human beings -- Migrations; Mummies
For Perry’s work in this field, no less than for my own, Rivers’
illuminating and truly epoch-making researches (=64= to =70=)
have cleared the ground. Not only has he removed from the path of
investigators the apparently insuperable obstacles to the demonstration
of the spread of cultures by showing how useful arts can be lost (=65=);
but he has analysed the social organisation of Oceania in such a way
that the various waves of immigration into the Pacific can be identified
and with certainty be referred back to Indonesia (=69=). Many other
scholars in the past have produced evidence (for example =2=; =60=;
=61= and =98=) to demonstrate that the Polynesians came from Indonesia;
but Rivers analysed and defined the characteristic features of several
streams of culture which flowed from Indonesia into the Pacific. Perry
undertook the task of tracing these peoples through the Indonesian maze
and pushing back their origins to India. In the present communication
I shall attempt to sketch in broad outline the process of the gradual
accumulation in Egypt and the neighbourhood of the cultural outfit of
these great wanderers, and to follow them in their migrations west, south
and east from the place where their curious assortment of customs and
accomplishments became fortuitously associated one with the other (_Map
II._).
I cannot claim that my colleagues in this campaign against what seems to
us to be the utterly mistaken precepts of modern ethnology see altogether
eye to eye with me. They have been dealing exclusively with more
primitive peoples amongst whom every new attainment, in arts and crafts,
in beliefs and social organisation, in everything in fact that we regard
as an element of civilization, has been introduced from without by more
cultured races, or fashioned in the conflict between races of different
traditions and ideals.
My investigations, on the contrary, have been concerned mainly with the
actual invention of the elements of civilization and with the people who
created practically all of its ingredients—the ideas, the implements
and methods of the arts and crafts which give expression to it. Though
superficially my attitude may seem to clash with theirs, in that I am
attempting to explain the primary origin of some of the things, with
which they are dealing only as ready-made customs and beliefs that were
handed on from people to people, there is no real antagonism between us.
It is obvious that there must be a limit to the application of the
borrowing-explanation; and when we are forced to consider the people who
really invented things, it is necessary to frame some working hypothesis
in explanation of such achievements, unless we feebly confess that it is
useless to attempt such enquiries.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account