The Mind and the Brain: Being the Authorised Translation of L'Âme et le CorpsBinet, Alfred
Philosophy
The Mind and the Brain: Being the Authorised Translation of L'Âme et le Corps
Binet, Alfred
Mind and body
Existence or Reality is that of which we have an immediate
apprehension. This apprehension occurs in several ways. In perception,
in the first place. I perceive the reality of my body, of a table, the
sky, the earth, in proportion to my perception of them. They exist,
for if they did not, I could not perceive them. Another way of
understanding reality is conception or thought. However much I may
represent a thing to myself as imaginary, it nevertheless exists in a
certain manner, since I can represent it to myself. I therefore, in
this case, say that it is real or it exists. It is of course
understood, that in these definitions I am going against the ordinary
acceptation of the terms; I am taking the liberty of proposing new
meanings. This reality is, then, perceived in one case and conceived
in the other. Perceptibility or conceivability are, then, the two
forms which reality may assume. But _reality_ is not synonymous with
_truth_; notwithstanding the custom to the contrary, we may well
introduce a difference between these two terms. Reality is that which
is perceived or conceived; truth is that which accords with the whole
of our knowledge. Reality is a function of the senses or of ideation;
truth is a function of reasoning or of the reason.
For cognition to be complete, it requires the aid of all these
functions. And, in fact, what does conception by itself give? It
allows us to see if a thing is capable of representation. This is not
a common-place thing, I will observe in passing; for many things we
name are not capable of representation, and there is often a criticism
to be made; we think we are representing, and we are not. What is
capable of representation exists as a representation, but is it true?
Some philosophers have imagined so, but they are mistaken; what we
succeed in conceiving is alone possible.
Let us now take the Perceptible. Is what one perceives true? Yes, in
most cases it is so in fact; but an isolated perception may be false,
and disturbed by illusions of all kinds. It is all very well to say,
"I see, I touch." There is no certainty through the senses alone in
many circumstances that the truth has been grasped. If I am shown the
spirit of a person I know to be dead, I shall not, notwithstanding the
testimony of my eyes, believe it to be true, for this apparition would
upset all my system of cognitions.
Truth is that which, being deemed conceivable, and being really
perceived, has also the quality of finding its place, its relation,
and its confirmation in the whole mass of cognitions previously
acquired.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account