The mind of primitive man : $b A course of lectures delivered before the Lowell Institute, Boston, Mass., and the National University of Mexico, 1910-1911Boas, Franz
Science
The mind of primitive man : $b A course of lectures delivered before the Lowell Institute, Boston, Mass., and the National University of Mexico, 1910-1911
Boas, Franz
Ethnopsychology; Race
The explanation of these remarkable phenomena is not easy. Whatever
their causes may be, the change in form cannot be doubted. It might,
however, be claimed that the changes are not due to deep physiological
causes, but to the changes of certain external factors. The composition
of the immigrant population might be such that the people who came here
at different periods had distinct physical characteristics, and that
these are now reflected in the descendants of the older generations when
compared with the more recent immigrants. It can be shown, however, that
the differences between the Hebrews who immigrated at different periods
between 1860 and 1909 are so slight that they cannot account for the
type of the descendants of immigrants. This important point can be
elucidated more definitely by the application of a different method. For
this purpose I have compared the cephalic index of all immigrants of a
certain year with that of their descendants. It appears from these
comparisons that the differences which are exhibited by the whole series
exist also between the immigrants who arrived here in a certain year and
their descendants. This purely statistical explanation of the phenomenon
may therefore be dismissed.
More difficult to investigate is the hypothesis that the mechanical
treatment of infants may have a decided influence upon the form of the
head, and that the changes in cradling and bedding which are made by
some immigrants almost immediately after their arrival in America
account for the changes of head-form. If this were true, the continued
changes among the Hebrews might indicate merely that the American method
of cradling is used the more frequently, the longer the family has
resided in this country. A number of investigators have claimed that the
position of the child on the back tends to produce short-headedness, and
that the position on the side tends to produce long-headedness
(Walcher). There is good evidence that a flattening of the occiput
occurs when a very hard pillow is used and the child lies permanently on
its back. This is the case, for instance, among many Indian tribes, and
similar results might obtain if a swathed child were to lie permanently
on its back. The prevalence of rachitis in New York would favor
distortion due to pressure.
While I cannot disprove the existence of such influences, I think
weighty considerations are against their acceptance. If we assume that
among the Hebrews the children born abroad have a lesser length of head
than those born here because they are swathed and lie more permanently
on their backs than the American-born children, who can move about
freely, we must conclude that there is a certain compensatory decrease
in the other diameters of the head of the American-born. Since this
compensation is distributed in all directions, its amount in any one
direction will be very small (Boas).
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account