Is it necessary to remark that there is no evidence whatever pointing
to this as the early state of man? That it is merely an assumption
assumed to help along one particular theory of evolution, and is
contradicted by those modern researches tending to show that savages,
when actually degraded, are degenerate rather than primitive? Yet
Browne illustrates his text with an original pen-and-ink sketch of
this Missing Link. The drawing is extremely good and spirited. One
only wishes it were a photograph. And he continues: “Since blows could
not subdue the hostile rocks or streams [the rocks were hostile,
evidently, because they supplied caves, and the streams because they
supplied fish], our ancestor tried to subdue them with magic....
Self-preservation must have forced them to [the] certainty [that
spells would work], for without it self-preservation would have been
impossible. Man had to have faith in himself or die--and he would
not die. So he had faith [in himself, you will note] and developed
religion.”[159]
This is so vivid that it sounds like the description of an eye-witness.
And he goes on in a no less certain tone: “By the word faith we mean
that indispensable--and therefore imperishable--illusion in the
heart of man that, though he may seem a mere worm on the earth, he
nevertheless can make himself the lord of the universe. By the word
religion, however, we mean one special technique by which man seeks to
realize that illusion. It was by no means the first such technique to
be invented by man; and it may not be the last, either. Long before man
thought of religion, he tried to control the ‘powers’ of the universe
by [this] magic.”[160]
Very well. Man, once half ape, has become, in seeming at least, a mere
worm; but he entertains an indispensable and “therefore” imperishable
illusion that he can make himself lord of the universe--certainly a
strange conviction for either a worm or an ape to entertain. To support
this illusion, he first invents magic, which is an attempt to coerce
the “powers,” and then invents religion--which Browne later explains
as an attempt to “cajole” the powers. Religion and magic are merely
two different kinds of technic, each designed to fool the technician
until by dint of fooling illusion becomes reality. The “powers” are not
fooled because they are always enclosed in quotation marks, which I
understand to indicate that they do not exist. What next?
“He [‘dawn man’] saw on every side of him the fell and bewildering
‘powers,’ and illogically but naturally his first concern was not how
they worked but how they could be avoided.”[161]
We thus make our acquaintance with the Browne idea of “logic.” A
logical dawn man would have waited to be devoured by the fell powers,
imaginary or not, before trying to avoid them. Logic would have
compelled him to understand before doing anything else. Fortunately for
us, dawn man was illogical. He escaped extinction.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account