For example,[72] an “intelligent and refined young lady” related the
following dream to Freud: “Her husband asks: Should not the piano be
tuned? She answers: It won’t pay; the hammers would have to be newly
buffed.”
This, we learn, “repeats an actual event of the previous day,”--for in
every dream there is a “day-remnant” to furnish stuff for the manifest
content, as well as a suppressed infantile wish to give it its real
“meaning,” and some of this remnant at least must relate to the waking
experiences of the past twenty-four hours. Once we grasp the general
idea, we shall see meaning after meaning, each one deeper than the
preceding, revealing itself like so many skins peeled from an onion.
The lady’s husband had actually asked her about the piano; but that,
being real, amounts to nothing. What is more significant is that the
lady, lying upon Freud’s couch and relaxing, refers to the piano as “a
disgusting old box,” and says that it was one of the things which her
husband had before his marriage.
The outer onion-skin has now come off. But it promises to be so
unsavory that we would better drop this particular bulb and take up
another. For dream onions are not only laminated, but there are always
several onions to every dream. Let us regard the one from which sprang
the phrase, “It won’t pay.” The outer skin here was a visit the patient
had made the day before to a lady friend who asked her to take off her
coat; but as she had to go in a moment she replied that it would not
pay. And here again I am forced to drop the subject, or at least to
avoid the line of thought which is immediately suggested by a knowledge
of the symbolism here involved. Freud himself takes a new lead by
remarking that during a previous analytical séance this same patient
_had_ taken off her coat, “a button of which had opened,”--taken it
off with a gesture which seemed to say, “Please don’t look in this
direction; it won’t pay.” From which he concludes that among the many
things which “disgusting old box” refers to is “chest,” or “bust.”
Were this lady but an American we might now conclude (without
exaggerating the Freudian procedure in the slightest) that this means
“Pike’s Peak or Bust”; that this in turn recalls a bust which she went
on when she was younger and in the neighborhood of 142nd street, New
York, locally known as “Pike’s Peak”; that the peak of her ambition was
to marry a Jew--with incidentally a hidden desire to be peeked at; and
that because of her failure to realize these wishes she was piqued, and
suffered accordingly.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account