Here the psychiatrist distinctly gives to the childish wish that very
importance which would naturally lead to excessive repressive measures
and to abnormal interior reproach. Moreover, it follows that all of us
who are not “sharply distinguished from ordinary human beings” would do
well to lock ourselves up. For we are not only capable of entertaining
such a wish, we have--so Freud has been telling us through fifty or
sixty pages--already entertained it, time and time again. Which brings
us to our--
_Sixth and Last Assumption_: That the cure for hysterical symptoms (and
these include most of the ills to which flesh is heir) is the recapture
by consciousness of the lost knowledge of that circumstance which drove
the original wish-thought into the limbo of the lower psychic locality.
The procedure is for the patient to dream a dream, or if he cannot do
this to make up a dream, which the psychiatrist “analyzes.” Then the
patient lies down on a couch, “relaxes,” and repeats whatever random
thoughts come into his head as the various parts of the dream are
brought to his attention. These “associated” thoughts are analyzed
in their turn. If there is reluctance, the operator knows he has
encountered modesty (“resistance,” he calls it) and has got the range.
He can now tell where to train his guns. For all these neuroses,
psychoses and psycho-neuroses (mental troubles in general and their
physical results) are, according to the hypothesis, the children of
shame. Kill shame, and the brats perish. That is what it amounts to.
It may have seemed unaccountable that it should have been thought
necessary to invent an elaborate system of dream interpretation when
the psychiatrist is convinced from the moment his office door-bell
rings that he is about to be confronted with a case of suppressed
incest. But the hocus-pocus serves its turn. Never has the ingenuity
of man devised a more effective excuse for the discussion of the
abominations of the human heart.
“But,” cries Freud, “my analyses bring about cures!”
Granted. But that only proves that Freud the man is better than Freud
the scientist and philosopher.
The world is full of miserable wretches whose early education was of
the most atrocious kind; who were first permitted improper contacts,
and then taught that their infantile imaginings were unpardonable
sins. The doctor poo-poos the whole matter, and they are relieved. In
other words, if he is a wise doctor, he tries to remedy the defects
of education by re-education. So long as he has to deal with those
suffering from abuse, or from starvation of natural desires--desires
which have failed of their ordinary satisfaction without having been
sublimated by devotion to higher aims--so long as he deals with these
unwilling anchorites and pitiable social victims, he does well.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account