The Modes of Ancient Greek MusicMonro, D. B. (David Binning)
History
The Modes of Ancient Greek Music
Monro, D. B. (David Binning)
Music, Greek and Roman
(3) In a somewhat similar passage of the same work (c. 19) Plutarch
is contending that the fewness of the notes in the scales used by the
early musicians did not arise from ignorance, but was characteristic
of their art, and necessary to its peculiar ethos. Among other points
he notices that the tetrachord Hypatôn was not used in Dorian music
([Greek: en tois Dôriois]), and this, he says, was not because they
did not know of that tetrachord--for they used it in other keys
([Greek: tonoi])--but they left it out in the Dorian key for the sake
of preserving its ethos, the beauty of which they valued ([Greek: dia
dê tên tou êthous phylakên aphêroun tou Dôriou tonou, timôntes to
kalon autou]). Here again Westphal (_Aristoxenus_, p. 476) has to
take [Greek: tonos] to mean [Greek: harmonia] or 'mode' (in his
language _Tonart_, not _Transpositionsscala_). For in the view of
those who distinguish [Greek: harmonia] from [Greek: tonos] it is the
[Greek: harmonia] upon which the ethos of music depends. Plutarch
himself had just been saying (in c. 17) that Plato preferred the
Dorian [Greek: harmonia] on account of its grave and elevated
character ([Greek: epei poly to semnon estin en tê Dôristi, tautên
proutimêsen]). On the other hand the usual sense of [Greek: tonos] is
supported by the consideration that the want of the tetrachord
Hypatôn would affect the pitch of the scale rather than the
succession of its intervals.
It seems to follow from a comparison of these three passages that
Plutarch was not aware of any difference of meaning between the words
[Greek: tonos] and [Greek: harmonia], or any distinction in the
scales of Greek music such as has been supposed to be conveyed by
these words. Another synonym of [Greek: tonos] which becomes very
common in the later writers on music is the word [Greek: tropos][1].
In the course of the passage of Plutarch already referred to (_De
Mus._ c. 17) it is applied to the Dorian mode, which Plutarch has
just called [Greek: harmonia]. As [Greek: tropos] is always used in
the later writers of the keys ([Greek: tonoi]) of Aristoxenus, this
may be added to the places in which [Greek: harmonia] has the same
meaning.
§ 13. _Modes employed on different Instruments._
In the anonymous treatise on music published by Bellermann[2] (c.
28), we find the following statement regarding the use of the modes
or keys in the scales of different instruments:
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account