The Monist, Vol. 3, 1892-1893 : $b A quarterly magazineVarious
Philosophy
The Monist, Vol. 3, 1892-1893 : $b A quarterly magazine
Various
Philosophy -- Periodicals
“Fortuity; especially the absence of a cause necessitating an
event.”
This is absolute chance, the existence of which we deny. The “Century
Dictionary” adds the following little note:
“Absolute chance, the (supposed) spontaneous occurrence of
events undetermined by any general law or by any free volition.
According to Aristotle, events may come about in three ways:
first, by necessity or an external compulsion; second, by
nature or the development of an inward germinal tendency; and
third, by chance, without any determining cause or principle
whatever, by lawless, sporadic originality.”[12]
We understand chance as being, from certain premisses, an incalculable
coincidence, either not intended to be calculated, or, for certain
reasons, from a given standpoint with a limited and definite amount of
knowledge, not capable of calculation. Determinism, as we understand
the term, does not imply as the “Century Dictionary” has it in its
definition of necessitarianism, that “the law of cause and effect” is
“mechanical.” It simply asserts that the law of cause and effect holds
good universally, and that there is no effect that is not definitely
determined, according to the nature of the things in action, by causes
and all their circumstances.
NECESSITY AND CHANCE.
Mr. Peirce says:
“_All_ the diversity and specificalness of events is
attributable to chance—diversification, specificalness, and
irregularity of things, I suppose is chance—and this diversity
cannot be due to laws that are immutable.” (P. 332.)
Our world-view leads us to other conclusions; we say:
Every specificalness or particularity is such by possessing a certain
form and standing in a definite relation (in time as well as space) to
all other things of the universe. Of every concrete thing we can say it
is now and here, or it was then and there. It is or was made up in this
special way, and it stands or it stood in these special relations to its
surroundings. Proportions, relations, forms—these are what account for
the diversification and specificalness of all things in the universe;
they are what explain the irregularities of individual cases and of all
those events which appear as chance to him who, although he may be well
informed about the nature of a thing, does not know the relation of
its complex surroundings, exercising according to law their disturbing
influence upon its actions which otherwise would be uniform.
And since no two spots of space and no two instances of time are the
same, since the relations of every atom are different in every position
and at every moment of its existence, we need not be astonished to find
diversity and specificalness in this world of samenesses.
We do not believe in absolute chance, but we believe in chance.
What is chance?
Chance is any event not especially intended, either not calculated, or,
with a given and limited stock of knowledge, incalculable.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account