The Mormon puzzle, and how to solve itBeers, R. W.
History
The Mormon puzzle, and how to solve it
Beers, R. W.
Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints -- Doctrines; Latter Day Saint churches -- Doctrines
Then, it lacks wisdom when we look at the evil to be overcome. The
political evil to be overcome is the existence of a non-republican
government in Utah. The government now there, though _republican in form,
in substance is oligarchical_, the real rulers being the triumvirate who
constitute the First Presidency of the Mormon Church. The problem is, how
to remove that un-republican oligarchy and set up a republican government
there as elsewhere. Now, see what is proposed! _A legislative commission
of nine appointed by the President!_ Why, the present government there is
more republican than that proposed. The government now in existence is
republican _in form_ at least, and the officers are elected by the
majority of the people and represent them truly. But the Legislative
Commission would be not even republican in form. The people would have
nothing whatever to do with their appointment--not even the Gentiles. That
government would be thoroughly undemocratic both in form and substance;
and even if it would truly represent the _Gentile_ population, it would
only represent a minority of citizens, and consequently would be
undemocratic; for the fundamental doctrine of democracy is that the
majority should rule the minority. As a proper substitute, then, for the
present form of government in Utah, the Legislative Commission must be
regarded as strikingly wanting. It does not solve the problem. It is
unwise, inexpedient, and unnecessary.
Another law, which is far more just than the preceding, has been proposed
recently by ex-Governor Murray (in his last official report), and was
strongly advocated by Joseph Cook in his Boston Monday Lecture delivered
February 8th, 1886. It was also introduced into the House of
Representatives on April 1st, 1886, by Mr. Woodburn, of Nevada. It is
known as the "Idaho Statute," because it has been in operation in the
Territory of Idaho. _It disfranchises every man and woman who believes,
teaches, or practices bigamy or polygamy, or who belongs to any
organization or association which believes, teaches, or encourages the
practice of bigamy or polygamy, and renders all such ineligible to any
office._ That law would only disfranchise the Mormons, the disloyal
element in the Territory, and would put Utah in the hands of the
law-abiding citizens alone.
But it is open to the grave constitutional objection of interference with
a religious belief. Those who simply _believe in polygamy_ would be
punished by this enactment; but our Government, whether national or State,
has no right to inquire into _the beliefs_ of our citizens. It is only
when they carry their beliefs into _actual practice_ of that which is
contrary to the laws of the land that our Government can rightfully punish
them or deprive them of civil rights.
CHAPTER VII.
THE POLITICAL PUZZLE (_concluded_).
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account