The Mormon puzzle, and how to solve itBeers, R. W.
History
The Mormon puzzle, and how to solve it
Beers, R. W.
Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints -- Doctrines; Latter Day Saint churches -- Doctrines
Utah may well be called "_The American Ireland_." Ireland is practically
in rebellion against the Government of Great Britain, and she bases her
rebellion on wrongs and abuses. Utah is in practical rebellion against our
Government, and bases her disloyalty on the ground of injustice and abuse.
Coercive measures have long been tried with Ireland and have been of no
avail; and now Gladstone, the greatest living statesman, advocates pacific
measures. When he introduced his Irish Home Rule measure into the House of
Commons on the 8th of April, 1886, the most memorable day in the history
of modern English Parliaments, in his great speech (confessedly one of the
greatest efforts of his life) he said: "_Coercion, unless stern and
unbending, and under an autocratic government, must always fail_. Such
coercion England should never resort to until every other means has
failed. The basis of the whole mischief is the fact that the law is
discredited in Ireland. It comes to the Irish people with a foreign
aspect." So we have tried prohibitory and repressive methods with the
Mormons for thirty years, and they have failed. _They will fail to the
bitter end._ The longer they are tried, the worse the result. They will
only increase their enmity to the Government, heal over their internal
dissensions, bind them the closer together, and wed them more firmly to
their peculiar beliefs, which have made them objects of persecution.
History can teach us that; and so we believe that it is time to inaugurate
a change--viz., to work on the Christian plan, to overcome evil with
good.
The plan which I have to propose to overcome the existing political evil
in Utah and bring it into thorough harmony with our American institutions
has the merit of being _in strict accordance with Christian principles and
with American principles_, besides being, I think, _the most effective
plan_ in the end that could be proposed.
It involves THREE MEASURES, although the first is not absolutely essential
and is advocated solely because it would greatly hasten the time when Utah
would be redeemed--_i.e._, the time when the majority of the voting
population of Utah would be law-abiding citizens.
I. THE ABOLITION OF FEMALE SUFFRAGE in that Territory. This is one of the
good measures of the new Edmunds law. I believe in female suffrage as a
general principle; but I am opposed to it in Utah, as society exists there
at present.
We acknowledge that this measure may from one standpoint be regarded as
_unjust_. It may be said that it is unjust to punish the _women_ by
disfranchisement, and let the _men_ go free, especially as they are far
more guilty.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account