"Certain allusions to events then passing (which will be pointed
out in their place) prove that the original paper was written, or
at least completed, in the summer of 1582, at which time Francis
Bacon was studying law in Gray's Inn, while Anthony was travelling
in France in search of political intelligence and was in close
correspondence with Nicholas Faunt, a secretary of Sir Francis
Walsingham's, who had spent the previous year in France, Germany,
Switzerland, and the north of Italy, on the same errand; and was
now living about the English Court, studying affairs at home, and
collecting and arranging the observations which he had made abroad,
'having already recovered all his writings and books which he had
left behind him in Italy and in Frankfort' (see Birch's 'Memoirs,'
I. 24), and it is remembered that if this paper belonged to Anthony
Bacon, it would naturally descend at his death to Francis and so
remain among his manuscripts, where it is supposed to have been
found.
"Thus it appears that the external evidence justifies no inference
as to the authorship, and the only question is whether the _style_
can be considered conclusive. To me it certainly is not. But as
this is a point upon which the reader should be allowed to judge
for himself, and as the paper is interesting in itself and
historically valuable and has always passed for Bacon's, it is here
printed from the original though (to distinguish it from his
undoubted compositions) in a smaller type."
Spedding's difficulty in accepting this paper as from Bacon's pen really
lay in the fact that from the internal evidence it is obvious that it
was written by one who had himself travelled through, at any rate, some
of the countries described. The results of personal observation are
again and again apparent. According to Spedding, Bacon was in 1581-1582
studying law at Gray's Inn; according to Bodley he was on the Continent
making observations for his future guidance. The reader can judge of the
value of the external evidence. It is not conclusive, but the draft
being found amongst papers which were unquestionably Bacon's writings
and being adopted as Bacon's and published as such by those who found
it, the balance of probabilities is distinctly in favour of its being
his. As to the internal evidence much may be said. It corresponds as
closely as it is possible with Bodley's requirements as set forth in his
letter of December. It is exactly "the manner of return" Bodley wrote to
Francis "your friends expect from you." "And," he added, "if in this
time of your liberal Traffick, you will give me any advertisement of
your commodities in these kinds, I will make you as liberal a return
from myself and your friends here as I shall be able."
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account