_The Jews emerge into history, not a nation of keen spiritual
aspirations and altruistic ethics, but that pagan people,
worshipping rocks, sheep and cattle, and spirits of caves and wells,
of whom the Old Testament, tending towards its higher ideal, gives
fragmentary but convincing evidence_.
JAMES T. SHOTWELL.
_Consider Jahveh. Cruel god of a horde of nomadic invaders settling
in a land of farmers, he had his images, ranging in elaboration from
an uncut mazzebah or asherah, to a golden bull. He was plural by
place and tribe and function. What did the prophetic movement do
with his sacred powers? It identified his taboos with a written
constitution_.
HORACE M. KALLEN.
_The mental attitude of these priest-dominated ancestors of ours is
amazing. They were like children in the hands of unscrupulous
teachers. In reading these old chronicles it is impossible not to be
shocked by the incongruity ever arising out of the juxtaposition of
theory and practice_.
LLEWELYN POWYS.
Our Martian visitor, having withstood the blasts of the Zealot, is
approached by a Mohammedan who places in his hands the Koran and tells
him that it is a divinely inspired revelation, as revealed by Allah
through his prophet, Mohammed. Having already had some experience with
earthly religionists, the Martian is disposed to avail himself of the
historical evidence regarding the life of Mohammed.
He finds that Mohammed, from all accounts, was a demagogue, a charlatan,
and a victim of mental disease. It strikes him strangely that such an
individual should be chosen by Allah as his disciple on earth to make
known his commands. He notes Mohammed's appearance on earth in 600 A.D.
and wonders why the Creator should have procrastinated for such a long
time; but decides to read the revelations anyhow.
He discovers that "from the literary point of view, the Koran has little
merit. Declamation, repetition, puerility, a lack of logic, and
incoherence strike him at every turn. He finds it humiliating to the
human intellect to think that this mediocre literature has been the
subject of innumerable commentaries and that millions of men are still
wasting time in absorbing it."
A Hebrew next takes his turn at this obstinate guest and sets before him
the Old Testament. Again, the Martian is informed that it is an inspired
book actuated by God.
In his attempt to find the historical evidence corroborating this book,
the Martian finds that authentic history begins for the Israelites with
the constitution of Saul's monarchy about 1100 B.C. All that precedes
this--the deluge, the dispersal of mankind, Abraham, Jacob, Joseph, the
captivity in Egypt, Moses, Joshua, and the conquest of Canaan, is more
or less mythical.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account