When Franklin showed the nature of lightning, the voice of God was
displaced from that of thunder. The sciences of ethics and psychology,
like modern Franklins, show plainly that conscience is no more the voice
of God than is thunder. Schopenhauer, commenting on Kantian theology,
offers the suggestion that Kant was really a sceptic, but became
frightened when he contemplated what he thought would happen to public
morals if belief were to be denied to the masses. Nietzsche speaks of
Kant: "With the aid of his concept of 'Practical Reason,' he produced a
special kind of reason, for use on occasions when reason cannot
function: namely, when the sublime command, 'Thou shalt,' resounds." In
his old age Kant became more bold, and perhaps voiced his true views,
for we find that in "Religion Within the Limits of Pure Reason," he is
actively antagonistic to ecclesiasticism, so much so that, for
publishing this work, he was censured by the Prussian king, who wrote,
"Our highest person has been greatly displeased to observe how you
misuse your philosophy to undermine and destroy many of the most
important and fundamental doctrines of the Holy Scriptures and of
Christianity." Indeed, many a man approaching Kant with a firm theistic
belief finds his belief somewhat shaken by Kantian logic.
Schopenhauer's "Will" has nothing in common with the God-idea as
commonly held, and he was bitterly anti-theistic. In a dialogue entitled
"Religion," he places these words in the mouth of his character
Philalethes: "A certain amount of general ignorance is the condition of
all religions, the element in which alone they can exist. And as soon as
astronomy, natural science, geology, history, the knowledge of countries
and peoples, have spread their light broadcast, and philosophy finally
is permitted to say a word, every faith founded on miracles and
revelation must disappear; and philosophy takes its place."
Hegel's deification of thought or reason left no room for personal
immortality, and his query, "Do you expect a tip for having nursed your
ailing mother, and refrained from poisoning your brother?" is well
known. A vague conception of a deity whose existence can be proved, if
it can be proved at all, only by the abstruse arguments of a Hegel is
not a god of practical service to the theists.
Schelling was pantheistic, and Feuerbach played havoc with the
philosophic evidence for God and immortality and treated all religions
as a dream and an illusion.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account