The necessity of disinterment, under existing circumstancesCooke, William
History
The necessity of disinterment, under existing circumstances
Cooke, William
Body snatching; Human dissection
Here is a broad declaration from the highest authority, and comment
would but weaken its effect. To the great majority of thinking men, it
will appear as if I were going about to prove that pain was an evil,
by advancing arguments in proof of the necessity of Anatomy. But I
have good reasons for believing, that certain persons who talk loudly
about the horrors of disinterment, are quite unaware of the nature or
object of that science, which they would consent to sacrifice at the
shrine of an ill-directed, if even a praiseworthy feeling. Let me ask
these persons, whether, in the event of a painful and dangerous
illness occurring to themselves or their families, they would not
desire the attendance of that medical practitioner whom they believed
to be skilled in his profession? If any one of them reply to this
inquiry affirmatively, I beg of that individual to read again the
sentence which I have just quoted from Mr. Abernethy. Dissection and
disinterment are _both_ forgotten and forgiven, when agony distorts
the features of a beloved sufferer, or when death seems to be
impending over him; and when that science which but for Anatomy (_and
in the present state of things but for disinterment_) could not exist,
is ready at hand to relieve from torture, or to snatch from death. On
the other hand, how numerous are actions against surgeons merely for
supposed want of skill in treating fractures and other cases, when the
patient does not acquire that relief which he expects. Suppose I were
exposed to an action from my prosecutors for ignorance in that science
which they have just prosecuted me for studying, who would be more
ready to prosecute than they?
Lest, however, our patients should delicately refrain from seeking
information of their medical attendants, as supposing that they would
be unwilling to betray the secrets of their _art and mystery_, let
them be assured, that necromancy and juggling are not farther removed
from the _practice_ of medicine and surgery, than are reserve and
mystery from that _theoretical_ information, which every educated
practitioner is, at all times, willing to afford. Permit me, Sir, to
use this opportunity of detailing a case in surgery: a practice which,
in my opinion, ought more frequently to be resorted to, as a means of
impressing the public mind with a conviction of the value, _the
indispensability_, of practical Anatomy.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account