12. But now I perceive that you are saying that this is merely
translating books and wearying you with painting this mixed-up
affair. Believe me there has been a reason why you should be
reminded of some of these things; for you see that you ask me to
describe the art of writing plays in Spain, where whatever is written
is in defiance of art; and to tell how they are now written contrary
to the ancient rule and to what is founded on reason, is to ask me to
draw on my experience, not on art, for art speaks truth which the
ignorant crowd gainsays.
13. If then, you desire art, I beseech you, men of genius, to read
the very learned Robortello of Udine and you will see in what he says
concerning Aristotle and especially in what he writes about comedy,
as much as is scattered among many books; for everything of today is
in a state of confusion.
14. If you wish to have my opinion of the comedies which now have the
upper hand and to know why it is necessary that the crowd with its
laws should maintain the vile chimera of this comic monster, I will
tell you what I hold, and do you pardon me, since I must obey whoever
has power to command me,--that, gilding the error of the crowd, I
desire to tell you of what sort I would have them; for there is no
recourse but to follow art observing a mean between the two extremes.
15. Let the subject be chosen and do not be amused,--may you excuse
these precepts!--if it happens to deal with kings; tho, for that
matter, I understand that Philip the Prudent, King of Spain and our
lord, was offended at seeing a king in them; either because the
matter was hostile to art or because the royal authority ought not to
be represented among the lowly and the vulgar.
16. This is merely turning back to the Old Comedy, where we see that
Plautus introduced gods, as in his 'Amphitryon' he represents
Jupiter. God knows that I have difficulty in giving this my
approbation, since Plutarch, speaking of Menander, does not highly
esteem Old Comedy. But since we are so far away from art and in
Spain do it a thousand wrongs, let the learned this once close their
lips.
17. Tragedy mixed with comedy and Terence with Seneca, tho it be like
another minotaur of Pasiphae, will render one part grave, the other
ridiculous; for this variety causes much delight. Nature gives us
good example, for through such variety it is beautiful.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account