The New Teaching of History: With a reply to some recent criticisms of The Outline of HistoryWells, H. G. (Herbert George)
History
The New Teaching of History: With a reply to some recent criticisms of The Outline of History
Wells, H. G. (Herbert George)
History -- Study and teaching; Wells, H. G. (Herbert George), 1866-1946. Outline of history
Like Mr. Gomme, Dr. Downey[2] has gone to the first edition of the
_Outline_, and, like Mr. Gomme, he has not checked his comments by any
reference to the current version. He is thus able to score very
effectively over phrases and passages that the owners of the book
edition will look for in vain. The weak point in the story of David and
Michal, as it was told in the part issues, for instance, has been
corrected, and my misstatement of the Sabellian view of the Trinity has
been put right. Let me admit that I did not know what Sabellianism was
when I wrote _The Outline of History_. Arianism I knew, and
Trinitarianism I knew, but not the views of the Sabellians. It was not
an oversight, it was complete ignorance that caused that misstatement,
and Dr. Downey is legitimately entitled to all the advantage this
confession entails. The fact remains that the second edition of _The
Outline of History_ does not contain the four or five words that
betrayed my ignorance of this refinement of doctrine, but gives instead
a correct statement of this Sabellian view. I doubt if there was any
general delusion that I was an expert in the theological disputes of the
early Church even before Dr. Downey called attention to the matter.
Unlike Mr. Gomme, who evidently found the list of errata at the end of
the Newnes edition of the _Outline_ very useful, Dr. Downey has not
troubled to look at that list. He would have found this Sabellian error
already set right there.
Footnote 2:
_Some Errors of H. G. Wells._ By Richard Downey, D.D. Burns, Oates &
Washbourne. 1921.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account