The New Teaching of History: With a reply to some recent criticisms of The Outline of History — John Shaqi
The New Teaching of History: With a reply to some recent criticisms of The Outline of HistoryWells, H. G. (Herbert George)
History
The New Teaching of History: With a reply to some recent criticisms of The Outline of History
Wells, H. G. (Herbert George)
History -- Study and teaching; Wells, H. G. (Herbert George), 1866-1946. Outline of history
Downey was thrilled a bit. Dr. Downey heads one page
“Exit the Ape Ancestor Theory”—it is what the London journalist would
call a streamer headline—because he has found an article by Major Thomas
Cherry pointing out the many reasons there are for doubting a very close
genetic connection between man and the living arboreal anthropoids. This
eager headline is followed on the next page by a still more eager
comment, by which Dr. Downey comes one of those controversial croppers
that _will_ happen in this sort of fragmentary discussion. He quotes
Major Cherry, “the specialised monkey foot may be ruled out as a stage
in the ancestry of man,” and adds, “sad blow to Mr. Wells with his
diagrammatic picture of ‘foot of man and gorilla.’” On several occasions
in his criticism of the _Outline_ Dr. Downey uses the dramatic phrase,
“one rubs one’s eyes.” Well, if he will rub his eyes again and have a
good look at that picture and read the context, he will find that it is
given to show the _difference_, not the resemblance, of the two feet,
and that the “sad blow” recoils with some severity upon himself. Because
it shows that I at any rate am tied to no brief, and have no hesitation
in giving a piece of evidence that may seem to qualify the general drift
of my story.
If Dr. Downey, by the bye, had looked up the current edition of the
_Outline_, he would not have found that figure. It has gone, and the
section has been recast so as to include an excellent note by Mr. R. I.
Pocock which makes it simpler and clearer.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account