The Norse discoverers of America : $b the Wineland sagas translated & discussedGathorne-Hardy, G. M. (Geoffrey Malcolm)
History
The Norse discoverers of America : $b the Wineland sagas translated & discussed
Gathorne-Hardy, G. M. (Geoffrey Malcolm)
America -- Discovery and exploration -- Norse
In the description of the personal appearance of the Skrælings there
is little that is decisive, but much that is circumstantial. One of
the two companion texts describes them as ‘swarthy’, the other as
‘small’. ‘Small’ sounds more like Eskimo than Indian, and may be
a corruption of the original text based on knowledge derived from
Greenland. Ugliness, unkempt hair, and broad cheeks would apply to
many Indian tribes, e.g. Micmacs, as well as to Eskimo. Large eyes
would seem at first sight to apply to neither, and Dr. Nansen therefore
considers it to be a trait showing the introduction of troll ideas.
Yet the eyes of Indians have struck many genuine observers as large;
for example, Lescarbot tells us that these features ‘neantmoins ne
sont petits, comme ceux des anciens Scythes, mais d’une grandeur bien
agréable’. Carver, again (1779), says of the Indians, ‘their eyes
are large and black.’ Verezzano likewise speaks of ‘large black eyes
and a fixed expression’. Another characteristic claimed by Nansen as
evidence of the influence of the troll-idea is the beard which we are
told was possessed by one of the Skrælings discovered in Markland: but
this strikes me as telling rather the other way, for all trolls are
bearded, and the Norsemen were so commonly so as to be known to the
Greenland Eskimo as ‘Long-beards’. The point therefore appears to have
been recorded precisely because of its rarity among the Skrælings,
and, while Indians for the most part take care to remove all hair
from the face and body, the possibility of beards among this people
is recognized by almost all writers on the subject (cf. Lescarbot,
Schoolcraft, Carter, Catlin, &c.). It may be admitted, however, that
the personal appearance of the Skrælings is not a point from which any
very clear inference can be drawn either one way or the other.
_The Waving Staves._
The savages whose appearance is described in these ambiguous terms
made their appearance in canoes on board of which—we are told—certain
objects were waved with a noise like threshing. The word used of these
objects is variously written ‘trjánum’, ‘trjom’, and ‘trjónum’. It has
been usually translated ‘staves’ or ‘poles’, but if ‘trjónum’ be the
correct reading it would seem doubtful whether something more in the
nature of a totem-mask or movable figure-head is not indicated. For
‘trjóna’ means primarily a snout, and then a detachable figure-head;
cf. the interesting passage in Landnáma (IV. 7) referring to an old
law whereby men were enjoined to remove their figure-heads before
approaching Iceland, ‘and not to sail to land with gaping heads or
open-mouthed snouts (trjónum) which might disturb the local spirits’.
It might on the one hand be argued that figure-heads are things more
intimately connected with the idea of boats than staves are, but for
that very reason a copyist would be more likely to convert ‘trjánum’
into ‘trjónum’ in the passage under consideration than to err in the
opposite direction.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account