The Norse discoverers of America : $b the Wineland sagas translated & discussedGathorne-Hardy, G. M. (Geoffrey Malcolm)
History
The Norse discoverers of America : $b the Wineland sagas translated & discussed
Gathorne-Hardy, G. M. (Geoffrey Malcolm)
America -- Discovery and exploration -- Norse
Possibly the Western Settlement was visited for recruiting purposes.
The visitors from Iceland, as we are told, only accounted for 80 men
out of the 160 eventually taking part in the expedition; the original
Icelandic crews, after a winter in Greenland, would probably need to
be brought up to strength, and the better part of 100 volunteers must
have been difficult to collect in so small a colony.[100] Mr. Babcock,
p. 97, seems to think that the shortest way to Labrador _via_ the
north was already known in Greenland, and he also, curiously enough,
considers it the safest route. On the question of danger there is room
for difference of opinion, but it may be pointed out that progress from
north to south or _vice versa_ is frequently impeded by ice till a
late date in the summer. The very slow Moravian mission ship, sailing
from London, often reaches the stations on the Labrador coast before
the Newfoundland steamer service, since, sailing from east to west,
she travels across instead of along the ice-barrier. Karlsefni’s
ultimate and principal objective being to the south, he would hardly
have deliberately undertaken so dangerous, unexplored, and roundabout a
course, even if he had known of the possibility, which seems extremely
doubtful. As a basis for calculation we may therefore safely put the
point of departure in the neighbourhood of Godthaab.
From this point we are told that the expedition sailed for two days
with a north wind, i.e. in a southerly direction. It should be pointed
out that the map occurring opposite page 106 of Mr. Babcock’s treatise
is very misleading as to the courses which it suggests. It contains no
meridians, and is tilted westward at an angle of nearly 40 degrees,
with the result that the Western Settlement of Greenland is brought
almost exactly north of the neighbourhood of Nain on the Labrador
coast, which is the point selected by the author for Karlsefni’s
landfall in Helluland. As a matter of fact there are not far short
of 10 degrees of longitude between the two places, and the course
between them is very far to the west of south. Mr. Babcock appears to
have chosen this point on the coast of Labrador in order to retain
the statement made as to the voyage having occupied but two days. The
distance being about 450 miles, the author is compelled to assume
a speed of nearly ten miles an hour, in support of which he cites
statistics as to the speed of yachts and other modern sailing vessels.
Now, as we have seen in Chapter V, this seems far beyond the capacity
of ancient Icelandic ships, and, since on this point we have definite
evidence, it is impossible that the time can have been correctly
stated, even if we suppose the very nearest point on the Labrador coast
to have been the land first sighted. It is moreover difficult to
suppose that Karlsefni made the nearest point; he had no clue to its
position, and his ultimate objective, for which he had a guide in the
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account