The Norse discoverers of America : $b the Wineland sagas translated & discussedGathorne-Hardy, G. M. (Geoffrey Malcolm)
History
The Norse discoverers of America : $b the Wineland sagas translated & discussed
Gathorne-Hardy, G. M. (Geoffrey Malcolm)
America -- Discovery and exploration -- Norse
On this island off the shore of Markland to the south-east we are told
that the explorers killed a bear, conferring in consequence the name
Bjarney (Bear Island) on the place in question. It has been generally
assumed that this must necessarily mean a polar bear. But Karlsefni was
acquainted with Norway, where the European bear still exists and must
then have been common, so that one would think that a bear which was
not white would equally be called a bear. I would further suggest that
this would be the case even if no bears other than the polar species
had previously been known to members of the expedition. But secondly,
supposing a polar bear to be meant, there does not seem any violent
improbability in the idea that one should be found, in the eleventh
century, so far south as Nova Scotia. At a far later date, Arctic
fauna had a much more southerly habitat than at present. Walrus were
regularly hunted in the Gulf of St. Lawrence, as is shown by a number
of passages in Hakluyt. As to the polar bear itself, its restriction
to its present northerly habitat appears to be even more recent. In
Labrador, as far south and inland as Eagle River Falls, Sandwich Bay,
Captain Cartwright records in his diary under date July 22, 1778:
‘Numbers were in sight. I counted thirty-two white bears, and three
black ones; but there were certainly many more.’ In earlier days
Jacques Cartier found a polar bear between Newfoundland and the Funk
Islands, while both Cabot and Corte Real found the same animal on what
was probably Newfoundland, and cannot certainly have been far north of
it. It may further be pointed out that white bearskins are mentioned
more than once in the _Algonquin Legends of New England and Nova
Scotia_, collected by C. G. Leland. As to bears on islands, whether
white or black, Cartier found them on Brion Island, so there is no
improbability in this feature. If a polar bear is meant, Sable Island
seems a possible location for Bjarney, but in any case there are many
islands off the Nova Scotian coast which would fulfil the conditions.
_Furdustrands._
Until, however, the expedition reaches Keelness, we are on very
uncertain ground, and it would be imprudent to insist upon any definite
conclusion. We may in fact, at this stage, so far as our information
hitherto has taken us, be either at the north-eastern extremity of Nova
Scotia or in the vicinity of Cape Cod, according as our identification
of Helluland and Markland agrees with Storm or otherwise. We may
however fairly say that the choice lies between these two localities.
Any other theory breaks down at the first touch of criticism.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account