The Norse discoverers of America : $b the Wineland sagas translated & discussedGathorne-Hardy, G. M. (Geoffrey Malcolm)
History
The Norse discoverers of America : $b the Wineland sagas translated & discussed
Gathorne-Hardy, G. M. (Geoffrey Malcolm)
America -- Discovery and exploration -- Norse
But when the description of Keelness given in the saga is compared
with what we know of the Nova Scotian coastline, one meets at once
with a very formidable objection to Storm’s theory. For here began
Furdustrands, the Wonderful Beaches, so called from their great length,
and thus described:—‘It was a desolate place, and there were long
beaches and sands there.... They gave the beaches a name, calling them
Furdustrands, because the sail past them was long.’ It appears too, as
already hinted, that this feature was sufficiently marked to give rise
to the application of the name to a large district, extending at least
to Straumsfjord (cf. second song of Thorhall the Hunter, see also p.
227).
_Mr. Babcock’s Theory._
Now the coast of Nova Scotia cannot, to an unprejudiced eye, be said
to comprise any continuous beach of a really remarkable length. On the
contrary, it is both indented and rocky. Mr. Babcock clearly sees this
difficulty; his remarks on the subject have been already referred to
(p. 234). He requires a continuous stretch of at least 100 miles for
Furdustrands, and this estimate compares favourably with those put
forward by Storm and most of his adherents. Now, to meet the objection
which is here raised, Mr. Babcock postulates a rise in the Nova
Scotian coastline since the eleventh century sufficient to account for
what is otherwise a fatal discrepancy in its present appearance. He
frankly admits that there is no direct evidence of such a phenomenon,
and indeed that ‘locally there is some scientific opinion that this
probably has not occurred’. But this is not the most that can be said.
In the first place, the early explorers who followed on the rediscovery
of the country found the coast exactly as it is to-day. The upheaval
postulated must therefore have taken place, if at all, within an
even shorter period than that allowed by Mr. Babcock. Thus Champlain
writes: ‘All the coast which we passed along from Cape Sable to this
place (Canso) is moderately high and rocky, in most places bordered by
numerous islands and breakers.’ Of Cape Breton Denys says (Green Island
to Louisburg), ‘All the coast is nothing but rocks.’ Thenceforward
‘nothing but rocks’ is a phrase constantly repeated, but one looks in
vain for any mention of a beach. Later on, ‘leaving there (St. Ann’s
harbour) and going to Niganiche (Ingonish) one passes eight leagues
of coast having shores of rock extremely high and steep as a wall....
Niganiche is not a bit better.’ Similarly right on to Cape North. We
have not much room left for these long and wonderful beaches, which so
struck the Norsemen immediately on their arrival at Keelness, and which
were so impressively long to sail past. It is true, as we have seen,
that there are white sands near the south-western end of the peninsula,
but the numerous indentations break up the coastline, and besides,
the description requires a cape facing a ship approaching from more
northerly latitudes.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account