The Norse discoverers of America : $b the Wineland sagas translated & discussedGathorne-Hardy, G. M. (Geoffrey Malcolm)
History
The Norse discoverers of America : $b the Wineland sagas translated & discussed
Gathorne-Hardy, G. M. (Geoffrey Malcolm)
America -- Discovery and exploration -- Norse
In the second place, had there been such a change as that suggested
by Mr. Babcock, at so recent a date, there must necessarily have
been positive geological evidence of it. When a beach rises from the
sea, particularly if it be of such great extent as is required in
the present case, traces of the former sea-level remain, in the form
of raised beaches, water-worn rocks, or remains of marine fauna. In
Nova Scotia such things are found indeed, but dating from a period
far antecedent to that with which we are at present concerned. The
formation appears to be contemporaneous with the existence of some
form of mammoth, whose remains have been found, and in many places
the course of these beach-deposits is cut through by river valleys
which have been formed since. (See Dawson, _Acadian Geology_.) Now if
these vestiges, dating from a period antecedent to the existence of
human remains, are still to be traced, it is clearly impossible that
no evidence should survive of what is alleged to have happened at a
date which is, geologically speaking, yesterday. Mr. Babcock’s theory
must accordingly be abandoned, in spite of his careful, ingenious, and
elaborate argument, and, this being so, we are still faced with an
insuperable difficulty in the way of associating Furdustrands with Nova
Scotia.
_Cape Cod as Keelness._
Now let us turn to the alternative suggested, and consider Cape Cod to
be Keelness. Karlsefni has now indeed been brought to a coast meriting
the name bestowed, ‘a desolate place, with long beaches and sands.’ Not
only does the Cape Cod or Barnstable peninsula, as Horsford saw, comply
with the description, but beyond this point the name Furdustrands might
appropriately be applied to nearly the whole Atlantic coastline of
the United States. Passing the shores and sand-hills of Cape Cod and
Monomoy, from Chatham at the heel of the promontory to Nobska Point
at the entrance to Buzzard’s Bay, the coast, as the United States
_Pilot_ describes it (p. 341), ‘is low and sandy.’ If the course lay
to the south of Nantucket and Martha’s Vineyard the same description
would apply. Here there is a slight break formed by the indentations
of Buzzard’s and Narragansett Bays, but the former is masked from the
sea, until passed, by the Elizabeth Islands, and the latter by the
islands at its mouth; the prospect throughout was an unattractive
one, and these bays, from the sea, might easily pass unnoticed, while
from Point Judith, west of Narragansett Bay, to the entrance of Long
Island Sound, by Watch Hill Point, there is still, in the words of the
_Coast Pilot_, ‘a low beach with lagoons inside and higher wooded
land at the back.’ Until arrival at Straumsfjord, no attempt was made
to land. As Mr. Babcock notices, the episode of Hake and Hekja is
obviously an interpolation from another source, as no vines had been
found up to the time of Thorhall’s versified comments on the subject.
We have consequently to look for but one indentation, that presented by
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account