Butler, Samuel, 1835-1902 -- Notebooks, sketchbooks, etc.
Good colour can never be got by putting down colour which is not seen; at
any rate only a master who has long served accuracy can venture on
occasional inaccuracy—telling a lie, knowing it to be a lie, and as, _se
non vera_, _ben trovata_. The grown man in his art may do this, and
indeed is not a man at all unless he knows how to do it daily and hourly
without departure from the truth even in his boldest lie; but the child
in art must stick to what he sees. If he looks harder he will see more,
and may put more, but till he sees it without being in any doubt about
it, he must not put it. There is no such sure way of corrupting one’s
colour sense as the habitual practice of putting down colour which one
does not see; this and the neglecting to look for it are equal faults.
The first error leads to melodramatic vulgarity, the other to torpid
dullness, and it is hard to say which is worse.
It may be said that the preservation of all the little episodes of colour
which can be discovered in an object whose general effect is dingy and
the suppression of nothing but the uninteresting colourless details
amount to what is really a forcing and exaggeration of nature, differing
but little from downright fraud, so far as its effect goes, since it
gives an undue preference to the colour side of the matter. In equity,
if the exigencies of the convention under which we are working require a
sacrifice of a hundred details, the majority of which are uncoloured,
while in the minority colour can be found if looked for, the sacrifice
should be made _pro rata_ from coloured and uncoloured alike. If the
facts of nature are a hundred, of which ninety are dull in colour and ten
interesting, and the painter can only give ten, he must not give the ten
interesting bits of colour and neglect the ninety soberly coloured
details. Strictly, he should sacrifice eighty-one sober details and nine
coloured ones; he will thus at any rate preserve the balance and relation
which obtain in nature between coloured and uncoloured.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account