Butler, Samuel, 1835-1902 -- Notebooks, sketchbooks, etc.
Surely the work done by the body is, in one way, more its true life than
its limbs and organisation are. Which is the more true life of a great
cotton factory—the bales of goods which it turns out for the world’s
wearing or the machinery whereby its ends are achieved? The manufacture
is only possible by reason of the machinery; it is produced by this. The
machinery only exists in virtue of its being capable of producing the
manufacture; it is produced for this. The machinery represents the work
done by the factory that turned it out.
Somehow or other when we think of a factory we think rather of the fabric
and mechanism than of the work, and so we think of a man’s life and
living body as constituting himself rather than of the work that the life
and living body turn out. The instinct being as strong as it is, I
suppose it sound, but it seems as though the life should be held to be
quite as much in the work itself as in the tools that produce it—and
perhaps more.
Our Trivial Bodies
i
Though we think so much of our body, it is in reality a small part of us.
Before birth we get together our tools, in life we use them, and thus
fashion our true life which consists not in our tools and tool-box but in
the work we have done with our tools. It is Handel’s work, not the body
with which he did the work, that pulls us half over London. There is not
an action of a muscle in a horse’s leg upon a winter’s night as it drags
a carriage to the Albert Hall but is in connection with, and part outcome
of, the force generated when Handel sat in his room at Gopsall and wrote
the _Messiah_. Think of all the forces which that force has controlled,
and think, also, how small was the amount of molecular disturbance from
which it proceeded. It is as though we saw a conflagration which a spark
had kindled. This is the true Handel, who is a more living power among
us one hundred and twenty-two years after his death than during the time
he was amongst us in the body.
ii
The whole life of some people is a kind of partial death—a long,
lingering death-bed, so to speak, of stagnation and nonentity on which
death is but the seal, or solemn signing, as the abnegation of all
further act and deed on the part of the signer. Death robs these people
of even that little strength which they appeared to have and gives them
nothing but repose.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account