Butler, Samuel, 1835-1902 -- Notebooks, sketchbooks, etc.
We should organise a legitimate channel for instincts so profound as
these, just as we have found it necessary to do with lust and revenge by
the institutions of marriage and the law courts. This is the _raison
d’être_ of the church. You kill a man just as much whether you murder
him or hang him after the formalities of a trial. And so with lust and
marriage, _mutatis mutandis_. So again with the professions of religion
and medicine. You swindle a man as much when you sell him a drug of
whose action you are ignorant, and tell him it will protect him from
disease, as when you give him a bit of bread, which you assure him is the
body of Jesus Christ, and then send a plate round for a subscription.
You swindle him as much by these acts as if you picked his pocket, or
obtained money from him under false pretences in any other way; but you
swindle him according to the rules and in an authorised way.
Real Blasphemy
On one of our Sunday walks near London we passed a forlorn and
dilapidated Primitive Methodist Chapel. The windows were a good deal
broken and there was a notice up offering 10/- reward to any one who
should give such information as should lead to the, &c. Cut in stone
over the door was this inscription, and we thought it as good an example
of real blasphemy as we had ever seen:
When God makes up his last account
Of holy children in his mount,
’Twill be an honour to appear
As one new born and nourished here.
The English Church Abroad
People say you must not try to abolish Christianity until you have
something better to put in its place. They might as well say we must not
take away turnpikes and corn laws till we have some other hindrances to
put in their place. Besides no one wants to abolish Christianity—all we
want is not to be snubbed and bullied if we reject the miraculous part of
it for ourselves.
At Biella an English clergyman asked if I was a Roman Catholic. I said,
quite civilly, that I was not a Catholic.
He replied that he had asked me not if I was a Catholic but if I was a
Roman Catholic. What was I? Was I an Anglican Catholic? So, seeing
that he meant to argue, I replied:
“I do not know. I am a Londoner and of the same religion as people
generally are in London.”
This made him angry. He snorted:
“Oh, that’s nothing at all;” and almost immediately left the table.
As much as possible I keep away from English-frequented hotels in Italy
and Switzerland because I find that if I do not go to service on Sunday I
am made uncomfortable. It is this bullying that I want to do away with.
As regards Christianity I should hope and think that I am more Christian
than not.
People ought to be allowed to leave their cards at church, instead of
going inside. I have half a mind to try this next time I am in a foreign
hotel among English people.
Drunkenness
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account