Butler, Samuel, 1835-1902 -- Notebooks, sketchbooks, etc.
I begin to understand now what Christ meant when he said that blasphemy
against the Holy Ghost was unforgiveable, while speaking against the Son
of Man might be forgiven. He must have meant that a man may be pardoned
for being unable to believe in the Christian mythology, but that if he
made light of that spirit which the common conscience of all men,
whatever their particular creed, recognises as divine, there was no hope
for him. No more there is.
Gaining One’s Point
It is not he who gains the exact point in dispute who scores most in
controversy, but he who has shown the most forbearance and the better
temper.
The Voice of Common Sense
It is this, and not the Voice of the Lord, which maketh men to be of one
mind in an house. But then, the Voice of the Lord is the voice of common
sense which is shared by all that is.
Amendes Honorables
There is hardly an offence so great but if it be frankly apologised for
it is easily both forgiven and forgotten. There is hardly an offence so
small but it rankles if he who has committed it does not express
proportionate regret. Expressions of regret help genuine regret and
induce amendment of life, much as digging a channel helps water to flow,
though it does not make the water. If a man refuses to make them and
habitually indulges his own selfishness at the expense of what is due to
other people, he is no better than a drunkard or a debauchee, and I have
no more respect for him than I have for the others.
We all like to forgive, and we all love best not those who offend us
least, nor those who have done most for us, but those who make it most
easy for us to forgive them.
So a man may lose both his legs and live for years in health if the
amputation has been clean and skilful, whereas a pea in his boot may set
up irritation which must last as long as the pea is there and may in the
end kill him.
Forgiveness and Retribution
It is no part of the bargain that we are never to commit trespasses. The
bargain is that if we would be forgiven we must forgive them that
trespass against us. Nor again is it part of the bargain that we are to
let a man hob-nob with us when we know him to be a thorough blackguard,
merely on the plea that unless we do so we shall not be forgiving him his
trespasses. No hard and fast rule can be laid down, each case must be
settled instinctively as it arises.
As a sinner I am interested in the principle of forgiveness; as sinned
against, in that of retribution. I have what is to me a considerable
vested interest in both these principles, but I should say I had more in
forgiveness than in retribution. And so it probably is with most people
or we should have had a clause in the Lord’s prayer: “And pay out those
who have sinned against us as they whom we have sinned against generally
pay us out.”
Inaccuracy
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account