The Numerical Strength of the Confederate Army: An examination of the argument of the Hon. Charles Francis Adams and othersMcKim, Randolph H. (Randolph Harrison)
History
The Numerical Strength of the Confederate Army: An examination of the argument of the Hon. Charles Francis Adams and others
McKim, Randolph H. (Randolph Harrison)
Confederate States of America. Army
The military population of Virginia in
1861, exclusive of West Virginia, is
estimated by Livermore at 116,000
Add one-tenth for extension of military
age down to seventeen and up to fifty 11,600
Add twelve per cent. for youths maturing
to seventeen in four years 13,920
-------
Total 141,520
Deduct exempts for physical and mental
defects, twenty per cent 28,304
-------
Available military population 113,216
But the representative writer in "_The South_" puts the number of men
furnished by Virginia to the Southern armies at 175,000, which is
61,784 more than the available military population! Could there be a
more palpable _reductio ad absurdum_?[13]
Besides, as I have shown, in Virginia and all the States there were
large numbers of men exempt as State officers. This considerably
increases the twenty per cent. which Colonel Fox says are in all
countries exempted from military service.
Take next Florida:
Her military population in 1861 was 15,739
Add one-tenth for extension of military
age down to seventeen and up to fifty 1,573
Add twelve per cent. for youths attaining
seventeen years in four years 1,888
-------
19,200
Deduct exempts, twenty per cent. 3,840
-------
Available military population 15,360
But the writer quoted by Mr. Adams states that Florida furnished 15,000
to the Confederate States army, and the War Office records show that
she furnished the Union army 1,270; making a total of 16,270, which is
900 more than the entire available military population!
Georgia.--Military population in 1861
was 111,005
Add one-tenth for extension of military
age down to seventeen and up to fifty 11,100
Add twelve per cent. for youths attaining
seventeen years in four years 13,320
-------
Total 135,425
Deduct twenty per cent. for exempts 23,085
-------
Available military population 112,340
But the alleged enrollment in the Confederate States army is 120,000,
which is 7,110 more than the available military population, making no
allowance for the failure of the conscript officers to put into the army
every man liable to military duty, and none for the thousands exempt
from service.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account