The nutrition of manChittenden, R. H. (Russell Henry)
Science
The nutrition of man
Chittenden, R. H. (Russell Henry)
Nutrition
TOPICS: Dietary experiments with a detail of soldiers from the United
States army. General character of the army ration. Samples of the
daily dietary adopted. Rate of nitrogen metabolism attained. Effect
on body-weight. Nitrogen balance with lowered proteid consumption.
Influence of low proteid on muscular strength of soldiers and
athletes. Effect on fatigue. Effect on physical endurance. Fisher’s
experiments on endurance. Dangers of underfeeding. Dietary
observations on fruitarians. Observations on Japanese. Recent dietary
changes in Japanese army and navy. Observations of Dr. Hunt on
resistance of low proteid animals to poisons. Conclusions.
General acceptance of a new theory, or a new point of view, can be
expected only when there is an adequate amount of scientific evidence
on which the theory can safely rest. Facts cannot be ignored, and the
larger the amount of supporting evidence the more certain becomes
the general truth of the theory to which it points. Corroborative
evidence, therefore, is always desirable, and he who would open up a
new point of view must be zealous in accumulating facts to uphold his
position. Critics there are without number who are ever ready to pick
flaws in an argument or overturn a theory, especially if the one or
the other stands opposed to their own point of view. This, however,
is highly advantageous for the advance of sound knowledge, since it
necessarily prompts the advocate to search in all directions for added
data, by which he can build a bulwark of fact sufficient to defy just
criticism. Further, the true scientific spirit demands persistent
and painstaking effort in the search after truth, that error and
misconception may be avoided.
In harmony with these ideas, our attempt to ascertain the real needs of
the body for proteid food led us to enlarge our evidence by a series
of experiments with still another body of men, _i. e._, a detail of
soldiers from the United States army.[61] This was a somewhat more
difficult and ambitious undertaking, since the number of subjects
involved was larger, and because with this group of men we could not
expect quite that high degree of intelligent co-operation afforded by
the preceding subjects. Still, this very fact was in a sense an added
inducement, since it offered the opportunity of experimenting with a
body of men who naturally would not take kindly to anything that looked
like deprivation, and whose continued co-operation could be expected
only by satisfying their natural demands for food. If this could be
accomplished by an intelligent prescription in their daily diet, and
the experiment brought to a successful conclusion, with maintenance of
body-weight, nitrogen equilibrium, health, strength, and general vigor;
with an intake of proteid food essentially equal to that adopted by the
preceding subjects, corroborative evidence of the highest value would
be obtained.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account