The old paths, or the Talmud tested by Scripture: Being a comparison of the principles and doctrines of modern Judaism with the religion of Moses and the prophetsMcCaul, Alexander
Religion
The old paths, or the Talmud tested by Scripture: Being a comparison of the principles and doctrines of modern Judaism with the religion of Moses and the prophets
McCaul, Alexander
Judaism -- Works to 1900
“R. Judah said, Rav said, Everything that God created in this world he
created male and female. And thus he did with Leviathan the piercing
serpent, and Leviathan the crooked serpent, he created them male and
female. But if they had been united, they would have desolated the
entire world. What, then, did the Holy One do? He took away the strength
of the male Leviathan, and slew the female and salted her for the
righteous for the time to come, for it is said, ‘And he shall slay the
whale (or dragon) that is in the sea.’ (Isaiah xxvii. 1.) In like manner
with regard to Behemoth upon a thousand mountains, he created them male
and female, but if they had been united they would have desolated the
entire world. What then did the Holy One do? He took away the strength
of the male Behemoth, and made the female barren, and preserved her for
the righteous for the time to come.”—(Bava Bathra, fol. 74, col. 2.) In
this narrative there are no marks of allegory. The creation of the world
is not an allegory, but a fact. The creating of living creatures male
and female is another fact. The weakening of the male and the salting of
the female to prevent the desolation of the world, does not look like a
figure. The Jewish commentators certainly take the matter very
seriously, and speak of the creation of Leviathan, not as of an
allegory, but as of a real occurrence. Thus R. Moses, the son of
Nachman, in his commentary on the words, “And God made great whales,”
after describing the great size, adds,—
ורבותינו אמרו כי התנינים הגדולים הוא לויתן ובת זוגו שבראם זכר ונקבה והרג
הנקבה ומלחד לצדיקים לעתיד לבוא . אפשר כי מפני זה לא היה ראוי שיאמר בהם
ויהי כן כי לא עמדו עוד ׃
“And our rabbies have said that ‘the great whales’ mean Leviathan and
his mate, for God created them male and female, but slew the female, and
salted her for the righteous for the time to come: and perhaps this is
the reason why the words, ‘And it was so,’ are not added, for they (the
race of Leviathan) did not continue.” (Com. in Gen. i. 21.) From this it
is evident that the famous rabbi knew nothing of an allegory, for he
makes this legend the reason why certain words used after the other
works of creation are not here applied. In like manner Abarbanel speaks
of this same pair of living creatures as real, and as possibly belonging
to the class of great whales.
ואם כלל הכתוב השרץ והדגה כאחד יאמר הכתוב שברא השם בהם מינים מתחלפים כי
יש מהם תנינים גדולים וכמו שאמרו בפרק הספינה אמר רבה בר בר חנא זמנא חדא
הוה קא אזלינא בספינתא וחזינא לההיא כוורא דיתבא ליה חלתא על גביה וקרח
אגמא עלויה . סברינא די יבשתא היא וסלקינן ויתבינן ובשלינן הם גביה דכוורא
ואיתהפיך ואי לא דהוה ספינתא מקרבא לון הוה מטבע . וכיוצא בזה יספרו גם
היום יורדי הים באניות . ואולי לויתן ובת זוגו שזכרו רבותינו מאלה היו עם
היות שהפילוסופים מבני עמנו ייחסו לאותה הגדה ענינים עמוקים מהחכמה ואין
צורך להם במקום הזה ׃
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account