The old paths, or the Talmud tested by Scripture: Being a comparison of the principles and doctrines of modern Judaism with the religion of Moses and the prophetsMcCaul, Alexander
Religion
The old paths, or the Talmud tested by Scripture: Being a comparison of the principles and doctrines of modern Judaism with the religion of Moses and the prophets
McCaul, Alexander
Judaism -- Works to 1900
“But if the Scripture class creeping things and fish together, then this
verse tells us that God created various species, for some of them are
great whales, as is said in the 5th chapter of Bava Bathra, ‘Rabbah Bar
Bar Channa says, Once upon a time we were sailing in a ship, and we saw
that fish upon whose back the sand remains and rushes grow; we thought
it was terra firma, and landed, and remained there and cooked. But when
the fish’s back grew warm, he turned round, and if the ship had not been
at hand we must have been drowned.’ They that go down to the sea in
ships in the present time tell similar stories: and perhaps the
Leviathan and his mate, mentioned by our rabbies, belonged to this
species. However, the philosophers of the children of our people
attribute to this chapter matter deeper than philosophy, but which we do
not want in this place.” (Com. in Gen. i. 21.) It is true that Abarbanel
here distinctly admits the existence of mysteries in that chapter of the
Talmud. But it is equally plain, that he considered the Leviathan,
mentioned by the rabbies, not as an allegory, but a real creation; and
therefore assigned it to the same class as the wonderful fish seen by
Bar Bar Channa, unless we take his words as a sly insinuation, that the
story of Leviathan is about as true as that narrated by the veracious
rabbi.
These two great rabbies, then, did not take the legend of Leviathan
figuratively; and we might add some other similar testimonies, but that
Behemoth also claims a share of our attention, and an inquiry into his
nature will contribute evidence to the same effect, that this legend was
not taken figuratively but literally. In the first place, D. Levi
himself refers us to Job xl. 15, and there we read, “Behold now
Behemoth, which I made with thee; he eateth grass like an ox.” Here
there certainly is no allegory. The words speak of a living creature,
and so they are interpreted by all the Jewish commentators, whom we have
an opportunity of consulting. Ralbag says—
בהמות הוא בעל חיים שמו כן ׃
“Behemoth is an animal, that is his name.” (Com. in loc.) Aben Esra, on
the words, “Behold now Behemoth, which I made with thee,” says—
בהמות שם בהמה גדולה אין בישוב גדולה ממנה וטעם עמך לפי שהיתה ביבשה כי
באחרית יזכור הלויתן שהוא בים ויש אומרים כי טעם עמך שהבהמות נולדו ביום
אחד עם אדם הראשון וזה דרך דרש ׃
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account