The old paths, or the Talmud tested by Scripture: Being a comparison of the principles and doctrines of modern Judaism with the religion of Moses and the prophetsMcCaul, Alexander
Religion
The old paths, or the Talmud tested by Scripture: Being a comparison of the principles and doctrines of modern Judaism with the religion of Moses and the prophets
McCaul, Alexander
Judaism -- Works to 1900
system of the oral law, which represents God as giving up all nations to
the influence of the stars, and then punishing them for following that
influence which He himself ordained, is nothing short of blasphemy, and
is much more akin to heathenism than to the doctrine of Moses and the
prophets. But, secondly, this passage of the Talmud contains two
statements directly contradicting each other. Rabbi Chanina says, Israel
is under the influence of the stars—the others say, Israel is not under
the influence of the stars; whichever statement we receive as true, the
other is necessarily false, and therefore the oral law contains
falsehood, and therefore is unworthy of credit. Thirdly, the story which
is here given of Abraham has falsehood on the face of it, and after all
does not disprove, but rather confirms the doctrine that Israel, as well
as the other nations, is under the influence of the stars; for as Rashi
tells us, Abraham and Sarah escaped from their sidereal destiny only by
changing their names. Rashi’s words are—
אמר לו צא מאיצגטנינות שלך שראית במזלות שאינך עתיד להעמיד בן אברם אין לו
בן אבל אברהם יש לו בן שרי לא תלד אבל שרה תלד אני קורא לכם שם אחר וישתנה
המזל ׃
“God said to Abraham, Go forth from thy astrology, for thou hast seen in
the stars that thou art not to have a son. _Abram_ is not to have a son,
but _Abraham_ is to have a son. _Sarai_ is not to bear a child, but
_Sarah_ shall bear a child. I call you by another name, and thus the
influence of the stars will be changed.” (Com. in Gen. xv. 5.) Here it
is plainly intimated, and that in the name of God himself, that Abraham
and Sarah were both under the influence of the stars, and that if they
had not changed their names, they never could have had a child. This was
evidently Rashi’s opinion; and when we remember that the majority of the
Jews in the world implicitly follow Rashi’s interpretation, we may
conclude that this is the prevailing doctrine. And perhaps some of the
readers of this paper may even know instances of Jews who, led by this
interpretation, have actually changed their name, in the hope of
bettering their luck, or even of escaping from death. But however that
be, it is easy to show that the Talmud and the rabbies generally believe
in the astrological influence of the heavenly bodies. In addition to the
passages already cited, the Talmud says expressly—
בזמן שהחמה לוקה סימן רע לאומות עולם לבנה לוקה סימן רע לשונאיהם של ישראל
מפני שישראל מונין ללבנה ואומות העולם לחמה לוקה במזרח סימן רע ליושבי מערב
וכו׳ ׃
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account