The old paths, or the Talmud tested by Scripture: Being a comparison of the principles and doctrines of modern Judaism with the religion of Moses and the prophetsMcCaul, Alexander
Religion
The old paths, or the Talmud tested by Scripture: Being a comparison of the principles and doctrines of modern Judaism with the religion of Moses and the prophets
McCaul, Alexander
Judaism -- Works to 1900
Every man who believes his religious
principles to be Divine, must wish that they should triumph, and that
they should have free scope for their development. Any man who dreads
the triumph of his religion must have secret misgivings that it is
false. We therefore ask every Jew whether he desires that the oral law
should attain that absolute power which it claims, and that every rabbi
and his disciples should have the power of excommunicating and
anathematizing all who affront them? One of the most perfect tests of a
religion, is to consider what would be its effects if supreme. At
present there are various systems of religion in the world, some of
which, as directly contradicting others, must be decidedly false. The
hope of all reflecting men is, that the truth will ultimately triumph,
that God himself will at last interpose, and establish the dominion of
truth and eradicate all error. Each hopes that his own system will then
prevail, but let him follow out that system, and see how it will work,
when all resistance shall be vain. Let the Jews calmly consider the
state of things, when the rabbies and their disciples shall be masters
of the world, as they must one day be, if Judaism be true. The unlearned
will then be completely at their mercy, their servants and their
bondmen. Will this be a happy condition, or is this state of things
desirable? In the first place, there will be no personal liberty. Any
man who may chance to differ from a rabbi, and treat him with disrespect
will immediately be excommunicated. In the second place, there will be
no liberty of conscience or of thought. Every man must then let the
rabbies think for him, and he must be content to receive their decisions
without any appeal. The body will scarcely have the appearance of being
free, and the intellect will be bound in fetters of adamant. It will no
doubt be a glorious period for the wise men and their disciples, but
they will always form a small minority, compared with the bulk of
mankind. The majority of Israel, not now to speak of the Gentiles, will
then be degraded into poor, crouching, submissive servants of the
learned, afraid to use their reason, and always having the fear and
dread of excommunication before their eyes. Do they then honestly wish
for such a state of things, to be tied hand and foot, and given into the
hands of their learned men? If they do not, if they see the horror and
the injustice and degradation of such a state of things, why do they
profess a religion which will inevitably lead to it, if it be true? If
such laws be unjust, and such a consummation dreadful, instead of
desirable, the religion of the oral law must necessarily be false; and
it is the duty of every Israelite to consider what he is doing in
upholding it. The present state of things will not continue always. The
Jewish nation cannot always wish to be wanderers in foreign lands. They
look forward to a restoration to the land of their fathers, and they
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account