The Origin and Development of Christian Dogma: An essay in the science of history — John Shaqi
The Origin and Development of Christian Dogma: An essay in the science of historyTuthill, Charles A. H.
Religion
The Origin and Development of Christian Dogma: An essay in the science of history
Tuthill, Charles A. H.
Christianity -- Origin
Mr. Matthew Arnold has given the clearest expression to the belief that
the religion of Christ was wholly undogmatic in character. The dogmatic
assertions attributed to Christ in the gospels, were, according to
him, used only in a mystical sense which the grosser-minded disciples
misunderstood. When Christ, for instance, spoke of his resurrection,
he meant that his moral system would triumph after his death; but his
disciples understood his words in a personal sense. Christ, Mr. Arnold
says, spoke “over the heads of his followers,” and, in consequence,
they failed to understand him, and ascribed their own ideas to him. The
evidence on which Mr. Arnold founds his theory is extremely slight; in
fact, he practically rests it on the few stories in the gospels where
Christ uses figurative language, which his disciples misunderstand,
as in the case of his injunctions respecting the “leaven of the
Pharisees.” Now figurative language of this sort is quite distinct from
the mystical language Mr. Arnold attributes to him, Hebrew literature
being full of the former and absolutely empty of the latter, and the
only resemblance between them is that they can both be misunderstood.
Mr. Arnold, indeed, by an elaborate criticism of the last gospel,
makes it to support his theory, its mysticism readily allowing this
to be done; but the fourth gospel has no historical value. The real
basis of the theory is the reverence which all men feel for Christ,
which renders it difficult for them to believe that he held opinions
differing from their own, and which also disposes them to imagine that
a vast distinction separated him from those whom he addressed.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account