The origin and development of the atomic theoryShipley, Maynard
History
The origin and development of the atomic theory
Shipley, Maynard
Atomic theory
Now, Philolaus was a famous geometrician as well as an eminent
physician and astronomer. Hence he--and presumably Pythagoras before
him--thought of these particles (or atoms) not in terms of various
qualities, chemically considered,--as Anaxagoras (500-428 B. C.), who
was not a Pythagorean, had done before Philolaus wrote--but in terms
of form (shape) and number. Each of the various substances known to
the ancient world as “elements”--generally recognized as compounds of
the real elements since the eighteenth century only--was regarded as
made up of particles of a certain geometrical configuration. Philolaus
explained that the “element” earth was composed of cubical particles,
fire of tetrahedra (pyramidal forms), and the “ether” was identified
with the dodecahedron (particles having twelve plane faces, or twelve
regular pentagons). In the _Timaeus_ of Plato we find this
conception further developed, bringing all the five regular solids into
the theory. Thus, the octahedron was now assigned to air, and the
icosahedron (a figure having twenty equilateral triangular faces) to
water.
Very interesting in this connection is the fact that the positions of
the electrons in atoms (the real elements) are being referred to today
in terms similar to those employed by the Pythagoreans. Take, for
example, the following passage from _Science Progress_ (London),
July, 1922 (No. 65), Pages 21-22:
“The modifications proposed in the expressions for electric and
magnetic forces allow of the electrons in [Sir J. J.] Thomson’s
model [atoms] to take up positions at rest at the corners of certain
well-known polyhedra, such as the tetrahedron, the cube, the rhombic
dodecahedron, the cubo-octahedron; and so in the sharing of electrons
between atoms and the consequent fitting together of such models we
have the explanation of certain facts of crystallography.”
But we know now that “fire” is not an “element” composed of tetrahedral
atoms; but the combustible portion of coal and wood is the real element
_carbon_--and the carbon molecule _is_ of tetrahedral form.
(See Bragg, Sir W. H. and W. L., “X-Rays and Crystal Spectra.”)
On the Pythagorean theory--as on that of Leucippus, and on the latest
theories of today--matter is broken up into parts (atoms) that are in
themselves unchangeable--apart from radioactivity--but produce by their
changes of position in relation to one another all the substances of
earth and of living organisms.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account