The origin and development of the moral ideasWestermarck, Edward
Philosophy
The origin and development of the moral ideas
Westermarck, Edward
Ethics; Ethics -- History; Prehistoric peoples
Most of the statements which imply a perfect absence of discrimination
between accident and intention, refer to the system of private
redress. Under this system a personal injury is regarded as a matter
which the injured party or his kin have to settle for themselves. It
certainly does not allow them to treat the offender just as they
please; as we have seen, it is more or less regulated by custom. But
at the same time it makes considerable allowance for the personal
feelings of the sufferer, and these feelings are apt to be neither
impartial nor sufficiently discriminate. Whether, in a savage
community, public opinion prescribes, or merely permits, revenge in
cases of accidental injury, is a question which the ordinary
observations of travellers leave unanswered. It is important to note
that one of the first steps which early custom or law took towards a
restriction of the blood-feud was to save the life of the involuntary
manslayer. Moreover, in many cases where the system of revenge has
been succeeded by punishment, the injured party may still have a voice
in the matter. In Abyssinia, for instance, "a life for a life is the
sentence passed upon the murderer; but, obtaining {232} the consent of
the relatives of the deceased, he is authorised by law to purchase his
pardon."[106] According to ancient Swedish law, an injury could not be
treated as accidental unless the injured party acknowledged it as
such.[107] In England, even in the days of Henry III., the king could
not protect the manslayer from the suit of the dead man's kin,
although he had granted him pardon on the score of misadventure.[108]
Indeed, so recently as 1741, a royal order was made for a hanging in
chains "on the petition of the relations of the deceased."[109] And to
this day English criminal courts, when dealing with some slight
offence, mitigate the punishment "because the prosecutor does not
press the case," or even give him leave to settle the matter and
withdraw the prosecution.[110]
[Footnote 106: Harris, _Highlands of Æthiopia_, ii, p. 94.]
[Footnote 107: von Amira, _Nordgermanische Obligationenrecht_, i. 382.]
[Footnote 108: _Three Early Assize Rolls for the County of
Northumberland_, _sæc. XIII_, p. 98.]
[Footnote 109: Amos, _Ruins of Time_, p. 23.]
[Footnote 110: Kenny, _Outlines of Criminal Law_, p. 23.]
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account