The origin and development of the moral ideasWestermarck, Edward
Philosophy
The origin and development of the moral ideas
Westermarck, Edward
Ethics; Ethics -- History; Prehistoric peoples
{289} In self-defence there should of course be a proportion between
the injury which the aggressor intended to inflict and the injury
inflicted on him by the person attacked. The most widely-recognised
ground on which life is allowed to be taken in self-defence is danger
of death. But it is not the exclusive ground. Among the Wakamba "a
thief entering a village at night can be killed"; though, if he is,
the incident generally gives rise to a blood-feud between his family
and the family of the slayer.[39] In Uganda "there is no penalty for
killing a thief who enters an enclosure at night";[40] and among
various peoples at higher stages of culture we likewise find the
provision that a nocturnal thief or house-breaker may be killed with
impunity, though a diurnal thief may not.[41] This law, however, seems
to have been due not so much to the fact that by night the proprietor
had less chance of recovering his property, as to the greater danger
to which he was personally exposed.[42] The Roman Law of the Twelve
Tables allows the diurnal thief also to be killed, in case he defends
himself with a weapon;[43] and, as regards the nocturnal thief, Ulpian
expressly says that the owner of the property is justified in killing
him only if he cannot spare the life of the thief without peril to
himself.[44] The same rule was laid down by Bracton[45] and by
Grotius. The latter observes, "No one ought to be slain directly for
the sake of mere things, which would be done if I were to kill an
unarmed flying thief with a missile, and so recover my goods: but if I
am myself in danger of life, then I may repel the danger even with
danger to the life of another; nor does this cease to hold, however I
have come into that danger, whether by trying to retain my property,
or to {290} recover it, or to capture the thief; for in all these
cases I am acting lawfully according to my right."[46]
[Footnote 39: Decle, _Three Years in Savage Africa_, p. 488.]
[Footnote 40: Ashe, _Two Kings of Uganda_, p. 294.]
[Footnote 41: _Ta Tsing Leu Lee_, sec. cclxxvii. p. 297 (Chinese).
_Exodus_, xxii. 2 _sq._ _Lex Duodecim Tabularum_, viii. 11 _sq._
Plato, _Leges_, ix. 874. _Lex Baiuwariorum_, ix. (viii.) 5. Du Boys,
_Histoire du droit criminel de l'Espagne_, p. 288 (Spanish
Partidas).]
[Footnote 42: _Cf._ Gregory IX. _Decretales_, v. 12. 3; _Mishna_, fol.
72, quoted by Rabbinowicz, _Législation criminelle du Talmud_, p. 122.]
[Footnote 43: _Lex Duodecim Tabularum_, viii. 12. Cicero, _Pro
Milone_, 3 (9).]
[Footnote 44: _Digesta_, xlviii. 8. 9.]
[Footnote 45: Bracton, _op. cit._ fol. 144 b, vol. ii. 464 _sq._]
[Footnote 46: Grotius, _De jure belli et pacis_, ii. 1. 12. 1.]
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account