Archaeology; Civilization, Ancient; Despotism; Greece -- History -- To 146 B.C.; Wealth
The view here set forth as to the basis of the tyrant’s power finds
nothing to contradict it in the fifth century references to the early
tyranny. On the contrary such few references as are explicitly made to
the origin of the tyranny by writers of the fifth century bear it out.
“Is it not folly,” says Oedipus to Kreon in the _Oedipus Tyrannus_ of
Sophocles, “this attempt of yours, without a host of followers and
friends to seek a tyranny, a thing that’s gained only with hosts of
followers and money[47]?” “When Greece,” says Thucydides, in his
introductory sketch of early Greek history, “had grown more powerful,
and was still more than before engaged in the acquisition of wealth,
tyrannies were established in the cities[48].” Herodotus gives no
account of the rise of tyranny, but a large proportion of the evidence
as to the careers of individual tyrants is derived from his work.
Perhaps the fifth century writer who might be expected to throw most
light on the question is Pindar, who visited the courts of the Sicilian
tyrants and wrote odes in their honour. His poems contain many
references to the supreme importance of wealth:
Wealth adorned with virtues
Brings opportunity for this and that[49].
Ever in the quest of noble achievements
Toil and outlay strive after the issue[50].
So elsewhere[51] in a similar spirit he describes Hiero’s great victory
over the Etruscans as “the crown of his lordly wealth.” The Syracusan
monarchs of the early fifth century seem to have had fewer affinities
with the commercial tyrants of the two preceding centuries than with the
military despots of a later age. It is therefore all the more
significant that wealth is so frequently regarded by Pindar, who more
than any other writer represents the transition from the sixth century
to the fifth, rather as a means to power than as one of its rewards.
Later documents, as has been said already, give a different account of
the early tyrants’ antecedents. But here and there statements are to be
found in them that, though perhaps reconcilable with other views, only
become fully significant on the commercial theory.
Isocrates for instance speaks of the “huge wage bills and expenditures
of money by which all modern dynasts maintain their power[52].” He wrote
these words between 342 and 339 B.C.[53], but as his modern times are
contrasted with those of Agamemnon and he himself was nearly thirty
years old at the close of the fifth century, his modern dynasts may well
include sixth century tyrants like Peisistratus and Polycrates, the more
so as “dynasts” arose so seldom in fifth century Greece.
[Sidenote: (_c_) some statements of fourth century writers,]
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account