How is it, then, that this theory has been discredited and lost ground?
Simply, I imagine, because it was thought to necessitate the turning over
of the animal. Let us, then, again look at the nervous system of the
vertebrate, and see whether there is any such necessity.
As previously mentioned, the comparison of the two central nervous systems
showed such close resemblances as to force those anatomists who supported
this theory to the conclusion that the infundibular tube was in the
position of the original oesophagus; they therefore looked for the remains
of a mouth opening in the dorsal roof of the brain, but did not attempt to
explain the extraordinary fact that the infundibular tube is only a ventral
offshoot from the tube of the central nervous system. Yet this latter tube
{37}is one, if not the most striking, of the peculiarities which
distinguish the vertebrate; a tubular central nervous system such as that
of the vertebrate is totally unlike any other nervous system, and the very
fact that the two nervous systems of the vertebrate and arthropod are so
similar in their nervous arrangements, makes it still more extraordinary
that the nervous system should be grouped round a tube in the one case and
not in the other.
Now, in the arthropod the oesophagus leads directly into the stomach, which
is situated in the head-region, and from this a straight intestine passes
directly along the length of the body to the anus, where it terminates. The
relations of mouth, oesophagus, alimentary canal, and nervous system in
these animals are represented in the diagram (Fig. 3).
Any tube, therefore, such as that of the infundibulum, which would
represent the oesophagus of such an animal, must have opened into the mouth
on the ventral side, and into the stomach on the dorsal side, and the
lining epithelium of such an oesophagus must have been continuous with that
of the stomach, and so of the whole intestinal tract.
Supposing, then, the animal is not turned over, but that the dorsal side
still remains dorsal and ventral ventral, then the original mouth-opening
of the oesophagus must be looked for on the ventral surface of the
vertebrate brain in the region of the pituitary body or hypophysis, and on
the dorsal side the tube representing the oesophagus must be continuous
with a large cephalically dilated tube, which ought to pass into a small
canal, to run along the length of the body and terminate in the anus.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account